 |
|
Ned
|
 |
of Aptos, CA
Oct 1999
time: 21:26
|
|
Big Crunch, Certainly this was true after the Allies had taken out Ploesti. But to the extent it was true even before then, which is quite possible, it simply indicates that Germany could not have won the war regardless of how high tech her machines were. They had no fuel.
Last edited by Ned on 26-02-2003 at 07:36
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Ned
|
|
of Aptos, CA
Oct 1999
time: 21:26
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by GePap
MOre Jet fighters would not have turned the tide in the Eastern Front, were the Wehrmacht was evicerated, they would not have won the Battle for the Atlantic, and they would not have helped the Germans aquire the necessary raw materials, specially oil, it needed to win the war.
The importance of strategic bombing against Germany is overrated. More jets might have cut back bombing of factoires far from the front, but they would not have helped Germany aquire control of the air over the battlefields or stopped tactical and mdedium bombers form cutting supply lines.
By Jan 1943 the question was when germany would loose, not whether. |
As Georing said, had they mass produced the ME 262 fighter from 1942 on, the Germans may have controlled the skies, not the other way around. Who knows what German air superiority would have meant. Air power was often decisive in defeating the German army which across the board had superior equipment to the Allies.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Ned
|
|
of Aptos, CA
Oct 1999
time: 21:26
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by GePap
And the Germans would have flown these planes with what oil? Oil was the critical factor. to train pilots you need to give them flying time. flying time means using fuel . If you have limited fuel, you cut back on training time of pilots.
I trust Goering's word as far as I can thrown him, and we all know how heavyset a man he was. He has self-serving reasons to say what he said, one fo them is not admitting that invading the SU and declaring war on the Us were immensely stupid dieas and sealed their fate.
What would control fo the air had meant in the East? The ME-262 was a great interceptor, not a great dogfighter, and a lousy tactical support aircraft. 2000 ME-262's a year would not have allowed the Germans to overcome the masses of Soviet armor, or allowed them to stop the US from shipping millions of men and millions of tons of equipment accross the ocean.
Perhaps the Germans could ahv amde the war a few month longer: but Jets would not have led to victory. |
Well, GePap, you are right about the jets being useless as tactical air support. However, the Germans still had dive bombers and wire guided missles. If they air superiority, they could have used these to great effect against Russian and US armor.
But you are right, even before Ploesti was destroyed, they didn't have enough fuel. This makes one pause and consider that they should have done a lot more to secure the Mediterranean before they went on their adventures in the SU. Lybia could have been the oil supply.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Tingkai
|
|
To find the Northwest Passage
Aug 2001
time: 13:26
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by Ned
But, from my understanding the Germans did not have enough pilots to put up much of a fight from mid-1944 onwards. This is when the Mustang began to dominate. (I only half recall the dates.) |
Assuming this is true, and it probably is, by mid-1944 the Germans did not have a secure training area. Allied fighters, including a/c other than the Mustang, were doing sorties throughout Germany. Pilots in training risked being shot down on their first solo.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Tattila the Hun
|
 |
Tornio
Oct 2002
time: 07:26
|
|
I recently read a book by Heinz Kröger, one of Germany's top "four engine downers", ie. heavy bomber killers. It was stated in the book, that in the final years of the war, allies resorted in quite nasty tactics to rid Luftwaffe from it's best pilots, eg. shooting parachuted pilots on their descent. Also, the jagdfliegerschüle were effectively emptied of their instructors, who were assigned to frontline squadrons. "The great hunt", the book is called, has some interesting stories about the Me-109 actually bombing the mighty eight's formations with regular bombs.
I was under the impression that japanese jets were mostly copies of german designs, the Me-262 and 163 most notably...
Some other interesting consept include the Natter, a plane somewhat similar to Komet, with rockets as ammunition on the plane's nose, or the manned (!) V-1 rocket (never used). The pilot would bail out at the last moment, he's chances of survival being somewhat slim. Then there's the Heinkel He-160, Volksjäger, plywood design, meant for Hitlerjugend to fly after few glider lessons... A high powered jet fighter, usually quite fatal even for the more experienced test pilot... And then there was a rocket, launched from the top of the fighter by the shadow of the bomber...
Anybody who is interested in the rise and fall of Luftwaffe, and their machines, and the wacky designs that were to be, should read a book called "Hitler's Luftwaffe", author(s) currently escaping me.
Other what if's include the Graf Zeppelin, an aircraft carrier. Can't really say what an impact it might have had on the batte of britain and such...
And the Maus. Lynx, Puma, Panther, Tiger... And the biggest of them, the Maus. Atleast they had sense of humour... Quite unconvenient machine, usually quite stuck in mud or something, and breaking the pawement of roads, all because it was (very) heavy.
Them german's indeed had some interesting designs...
If anybody has any good links to interesting site's concerning the techs and applications and what if's, do post them.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
CerberusIV
|
|
Interesting stuff but there is a wide range of opinion on how useful the german wonder weapons would have been. I have an interesting book on the subject which covers a much wider range than has been mentioned here. I will post the title and reference when I get home this evening.
A few thoughts do occur to me.
The germans built two nuclear piles, both were rather small to function effectively and they were some years from a working atomic bomb. They also didn't have a heavy bomber that would effectively deliver such a weapon. It took the US nearly 10 years to get nuclear weapons to a size and weight that smaller aircraft could use.
The Luftwaffe problem was partly that the factories were producing obselete designs like the Me109 which was fairly hopeless against P51's. Once the USAAF had long range fighters it was able to destroy the factories making fuel out of oil shale by precise daylight strikes. End of fuel, end of Luftwaffe. Even a mass suicide ramming attempt failed to make any impact on the B17 fleets.
The weapon that might have had a significant impact but came too late was the type XXI U-boat. The UK may have been America's unsinkable aircraft carrier but cutting the maritime supply route, especially oil tankers would have crippled the air units operating out of the UK.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
CerberusIV
|
|
For a good rundown of the German secret weapons that actually made it off the drawing board try
German Secret Weapons of the Second World War
Ian V Hogg
ISBN 1-85367-325-0
The reasons given why so many German wonderweapons did not appear in sufficient numbers in time is enlightening.
For an impression of the last days of the Luftwaffe try
KG200 The True Story
P W Stahl
ISBN 0 531 03729 0
|
|
| |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:26.
Apolyton Time is 00:26. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|
26-02-2003 03:08
I don't recall any turkey shoots against inexperienced German pilots. Any additional info.
|