Apolyton Archive  |  Preserved copy of the Apolyton Civilization Site and its forums as they stood in September 2005. Read-only; nothing here can be posted to or replied to.  |  Forum index |  About this archive |  The 1998–2001 UBB forums
Today on Apolyton WARDELL INTERVIEW PROMO A.C.S. HISTORY CHAPTER 4 GET CIV4 /w FREE PLUS! A.C.S. PHOTO GALLERY GET A.O.M. V1.1
Apolyton Civilization Forums
main| civ2| civ3| civ4| smac| ctp2| ron| moo3| galciv| galciv2| alt| about|
ApolytonPLUS | register | search | faq | new posts | pm (-/-) | upload | members
hall of fame new! | civgroups | civgroups news | interviews | the column | radio | chat | directory | news | store | PLUS
Apolyton Civilization Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.0.3 Apolyton Civilization Forums > Miscellaneous > Archive > Off-Topic-Archive > How were the american indians subjugated?
Show a Printable Version | Email This Page to Someone! | Receive updates to this thread | Report this to Apolyton news!

bottom of page
  
Author
Thread   
Pages (4): [ 1   2   3   4   ]
< Last Thread     Next Thread > Post New Thread     Post A Reply
Dis is offline Dis
Emperor
Las Vegas, Nevada
Feb 2000
time: 21:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:32 Visit Dis's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#1 Report this post to a moderator
How were the american indians subjugated? Got spare money?

I admit I'm not very well versed on the history of the american indians in the late 19th century. Most of my knowledge comes from western movies .

But I can't help but see some similarities of the actions of the american indians and modern day terrorists. Both saw/see western civilization as an affront to their culture and well being. And both have attacked common civilians to try to achieve objectives. And I'm thinking perhaps there is a solution to our current problems here.

From what I understand, we used overwhelming military force to subjugate the american indians. This is often seen as an atrocity by today's standards, but it got the job done. There were occasional problems such as General Custer, but for the most part I believe the army was successful, although very ruthless.

Perhaps this is why I support overwhelming military force against terrorists. Yes it is painful, many will consider it morally wrong and even unlawful. But I still believe it is the best recourse against terrorism.

What do you think? Where am I wrong? Enlighten me. This is your thread to discuss late 19th century american history in the west. Or did problems persist into the 20th century? I do recall problems with Pancho Villa, but he was mexican, and had different motivations. Actually it doesn't even have to be late 19th century. There were problems way before that. But it was during that time period that things really began to fall in place it seems to me. Or am I wrong?

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:33
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#2 Report this post to a moderator
Increase Your PM Length

Disease, a lot. That and simply being displaced.

yavoon is offline yavoon
Warlord

Oct 2001
time: 05:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:37
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#3 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations: Deluxe Edition

kill 90% of them and occupy their land?

gotta admit, that'd be effective!

jdd2007 is offline jdd2007
King
Cincinnati
Aug 2001
time: 00:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:39 Visit jdd2007's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#4 Report this post to a moderator
Lose 30 kilos (of popups)

We were the aggressors 99 of 100 times.

PeteH is offline PeteH
Settler

Jan 2003
time: 05:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:50
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#5 Report this post to a moderator
Help yourself to an AD-FREE life

http://www.zmag.org/zmag/articles/may97churchill.html

is not a bad place to start. Ward Churchill has written extensively on Indian issues, I recenly finished a collection of a handful of essays "A Little Matter of Genocide" exploring the concepts and efinitions surrounding genocide, but in more direct relation to your question is the selection "Nits Make Lice": The extermination of north american indians 1607-1996

I would also recommend "American Holocost" by David Stannard.

In general though a quote from Red Cloud sums it up well: "They made us many promises. More than I can remeber. they only kept but one; they promised to take our land and they took it"

(edit: missed part of the quote)

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:52
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#6 Report this post to a moderator
Tired of ads?

quote:
Originally posted by yavoon
kill 90% of them and occupy their land?

gotta admit, that'd be effective!


Yup, you don't even have to worry about culture flips

Whoha is offline Whoha
King
The TOC is supposed to be classified guys...
Dec 2001
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:56
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#7 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization III: Complete

quote:
Originally posted by Kucinich
Disease, a lot. That and simply being displaced.


Good quote from the history teacher "If someone asks you what happened to the such and such Indians, A good bet would be disease wiped them out."

Sava is offline Sava
King
GO GO GO!
Mar 2001
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:56
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#8 Report this post to a moderator
Suffering from ads?

quote:
But I can't help but see some similarities of the actions of the american indians and modern day terrorists.
get a saw, cut your head open and check to see if you have a brain...

PeteH is offline PeteH
Settler

Jan 2003
time: 05:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:58
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#9 Report this post to a moderator
Tired of ads?

On epoint I would like to make explicit though, is I think the fundamental comparison in your post of Indians to terrorists, while I understand many of the similarities, due to the connotations seems a bit off.

The settlers were the ones who relied on terror in their operations. Scalping and mutilation of the dead were introduced by the english, who had previously used it against the Irish. The behavior of John Mason and company at the 'Pequot Massacre' so horrified the natives who had otherwise supported them in looking to battle the Pequots that they simply left the battlefield in horror, the burning of the village and slaughter of women and children while sleeping being so far from what they woudl ever consider as 'warfare'

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 05:58
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#10 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization 2

quote:
Originally posted by Whoha
Good quote from the history teacher "If someone asks you what happened to the such and such Indians, A good bet would be disease wiped them out."


In fact, disease was a huge factor. However, some of it was part of a sort of biological warfare on our part - blankets of smallpox victims, etc.

PeteH is offline PeteH
Settler

Jan 2003
time: 05:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:02
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#11 Report this post to a moderator
Put an end to popups!

One problem with just saying "disease killed them" is it implies the deaths were accidental, or even regrettable. The killing of a population by disease was not an unknown tactic when the first settlers arrived in north america, and there are numerous explicit examples of deliberate infection, not to mention the imposition of conditions which cause what would normally be a survivable sickness into a deadly condition. Just as the totals for the jewish holocost don't have a separate category for "died of disease" due to the conditions of the death camps and ghettos, it seems to me a disservice to discount the deaths of so many native americans by making it seem accidental

SlowwHand is offline SlowwHand
King
of The Cooler
Sep 1999
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:06 Visit SlowwHand's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#12 Report this post to a moderator
Get a bigger avatar today!

As was noted, disease culled the herd to extreme.


To give you some unrequested fact (I could go a long time on this ):

MOST movies one sees about the American Indian concern Plains Indians.
On both coast, they were slaughtered pretty handily.
Especially in California where the Spanish had already tried conversion.
They didn't convert, but they calmed.

The Plains Indians were dominant due to horses.
The Comanche and Sioux in particular.

While this aided them in war IN ONE WAY, it weakened them in that they were forced to spread out to accomade grasses for their remuda.
Each warrior had at least 6 horses. That's a lot of grass.
Population depletion or not.

In the far North, up into Canada, Blackfeet were the big dog.
In the mountains of eastern Colorado, Crow.
Sioux had various individual bands, and were the enemy of most other tribes.

In the central region, Chyenne were split into northern and southern tribe, and dominated along with Pawnee.

Comanche had Texas, shoving the Apache into New Mixico and eastern Arizona.

Pekka is offline Pekka
Chieftain
em seu burro dos pais!
Feb 2002
time: 07:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:10
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#13 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization III: Complete

The problem is, they started scalping white women. That's when the crackers got mad. They tried to rob trains, and they needed train protectors (also known as cowboys) who were almost as good horse riders and better with the guns with accurate shooting from the back of a horse. That made the train protectors win 9 out of 10 robbing attempts.

The Indians however came with a clever plan to let them smoke what they call pipes, but as we later learned, it was their ****pumps. Now that made the crackers reaaally mad and all kinds of STDs where flying out there. Chemical warfare if you will.

But the train protectors came up with a brilliant idea and developed the deceases to another level and started making peace with the Indians and opened up a trade market. Now, in their food they got it back but way nastier and killing. Chemical warfare they started, crackers ended it.

They offered the Indians a cure for the decease in exchange for peace and friendship, that's all they had to do, but this one war chief called Scalping Warrior, he just had to scalp one extra white woman who was the duaghter of the new mayor of the new town near Indian camps called Peaceville. They just didn't get the message, and this made the train protectors decide NOT to build the next railways through that city, it being too dangerous.

It later on collapsed the whole economy of Peaceville, because no shipments were coming in and they couldn't give the cure because the trains didn't come in, because they wanted to help the Indians anyway.

So, Indians thought that they should now get the cure and because they didn't, rightfully so, they retaliated and slaughtered the town of Peaceville, including all the children, women and old people.

The postman from Pony Express came to deliver the new message from the President himself, declaring peace with all means necessary with the Indians but there was no mayor or anyone else in the Peaceville to take this message. He got lost and rode next to the Indian camp where Scalping Warrior was eating the dead babies and was feasting on the mutilated sex organs of the white women and this was a big trauma to the postman.

He rode back like a wind, and told what he saw to the President. He had no choice, but to call off the peace.

And this is what happened.

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:14
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#14 Report this post to a moderator
Suffering from ads?

Pekka, that's biological, not chemical warfare

Pekka is offline Pekka
Chieftain
em seu burro dos pais!
Feb 2002
time: 07:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:15
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#15 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Alpha Centauri

Oh you're right.. my mistake. I got this history book I'm writing. I'm thinking if the govs want them to be used in schools. I think it would make a huge success.

History - And what really happened
by: Supercitizen

Verto is offline Verto

King

Mar 2002
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:19
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#16 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

I think all you'd get is another loss to add.

Pekka is offline Pekka
Chieftain
em seu burro dos pais!
Feb 2002
time: 07:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:20
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#17 Report this post to a moderator
Inflate your Upload Space

no way Verto.. you see that's where you are just plain wrong.

Verto is offline Verto

King

Mar 2002
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:23
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#18 Report this post to a moderator
Get a bigger avatar today!

Well, anyway, the Indians tried to tango with the Europeans, and they got spanked.

End of story.

SKILORD is offline SKILORD
King
Live free or Die
Mar 2002
time: 05:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:39 Visit SKILORD's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#19 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Alpha Centauri

We need some new 'Anti-terrorism disease' like the pox and the plauge for the Injuns.

Anyways the Injuns were a slightly different matter since they had far more support within their ranks than the Islamic Peoples have for terrorists.

Another neat strategy for the Indians was smacking them into reservations and making them dependant upon the 'White Man.' Slaughtering the Bufallo... Well... what is the Islamic Terror Buffalo?

Oil.

Well.... then to slaughter that we'd have to.

a) Drill domestically.

b) Start mass producing alternative fuel cars.

c) All of these above

War4ever is offline War4ever
Emperor
I live amongst the Red Sox Nation
Jan 1970
time: 21:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:55
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#20 Report this post to a moderator
Suffering from ads?

i was not aware that disease killed the native americans, i knew the spanish gave the incas IIRC blankets infected with smallpox when they first arrived, i didnt' think this was extended to the natives such as the sioux, cheyanne etc

Verto is offline Verto

King

Mar 2002
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:57
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#21 Report this post to a moderator
Suffering from ads?

Why wouldn't it have? The Sioux would have been just as vulnerable to disease as the Incas.

SKILORD is offline SKILORD
King
Live free or Die
Mar 2002
time: 05:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:59 Visit SKILORD's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#22 Report this post to a moderator
Increase the size of your Attachments

quote:
i knew the spanish gave the incas IIRC blankets infected with smallpox when they first arrived


Not the Spanish and not the Inca.

The British colonists did it frequently to the assorted woodsland tribes.

Verto is offline Verto

King

Mar 2002
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 06:59
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#23 Report this post to a moderator
Help yourself to an AD-FREE life

Are you sure the Spanish are innocent of that act?

War4ever is offline War4ever
Emperor
I live amongst the Red Sox Nation
Jan 1970
time: 21:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 07:00
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#24 Report this post to a moderator
Browse Apolyton AD-FREE

its not a questions of vulnerability, its a question of whether or not those tactics were used.

I know the indians were displaced, even more so as the railroad was put in,

i simply stated i was not aware that the english has used similar tactics of mass genocide in the forms of disease.

They did a thorough job though, very few indians left ....and someone pointed out before, it would be a war crime as heinous as any other if it were to happen in this day and age.

Verto is offline Verto

King

Mar 2002
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 07:03
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#25 Report this post to a moderator
Full PM-box? Change here!

quote:
its a question of whether or not those tactics were used.


The Indians were dying simply by coming into contact with the Europeans.

War4ever is offline War4ever
Emperor
I live amongst the Red Sox Nation
Jan 1970
time: 21:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 07:06
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#26 Report this post to a moderator
Put an end to popups!

It wouldn't be the first time in history something like this happened. In fact look at SARS and the scare it caused.

Disease is scary stuff, contact is what usually spreads it.

I will state again, i was not aware that it was used as a tactic on the american indian as it was on the incans.

either way, it was brutaly effective

Uncle Sparky is offline Uncle Sparky
King
Winnipeg
Jan 1970
time: 23:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 07:20
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#27 Report this post to a moderator
Help yourself to an AD-FREE life

Ask the Beotuk... oops, they were wiped out. My home city is considering building a Human Rights Museum. The organizers are trying to avoid a growing grass roots movement to install a gallery describing the horrific treatment of the North American first nations by the Europeans.

I live in the great plains. The first nations in the area were largely nomadic. They were settled into reservations (think South African homelands) not allowed to practice there own languages religions and culture. Kidnapped at early ages, generations were sent to Residential Schools (there are thousands of outstanding lawsuits for physical and sexual abuse suffered in these church run schools).

War4ever is offline War4ever
Emperor
I live amongst the Red Sox Nation
Jan 1970
time: 21:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 07:25
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#28 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy GURPS/ Alpha Centauri

does anyone know how many indians were killed in combat, how many died of disease and other attrocities?

i would be curious, i know the population was pretty much wiped down to 10% wasnt it?

Kidicious is offline Kidicious
Settler
Diety of Kidiverse
Mar 2003
time: 21:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 07:26 Visit Kidicious's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#29 Report this post to a moderator
Re: How were the american indians subjugated? Support Apolyton, buy Civilization 2

quote:
Originally posted by Dissident
But I can't help but see some similarities of the actions of the american indians and modern day terrorists.


I can't help but see the similarities between Americans and the terrorists, even the Americans living today, especially with idiots who believe this stupid crap.

SKILORD is offline SKILORD
King
Live free or Die
Mar 2002
time: 05:34
  Old Post 24-03-2004 07:29 Visit SKILORD's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#30 Report this post to a moderator
Lose 30 kilos (of popups)

quote:
Originally posted by Verto
Are you sure the Spanish are innocent of that act?


The spanish didn't use that particular tactic, but they certainly did their share of atrocities.

 
Pages (4): [ 1   2   3   4   ]
< Last Thread     Next Thread > Post New Thread     Post A Reply
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:34.
Apolyton Time is 00:34.
    top of page
Rate This Thread:
archivepost
Forum Jump:
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
 




Contact Us - Apolyton Civilization Site - Support Us!

Building a better Apolyton through better information. Click here and take our poll!
Non-US visitors, click here!

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.0.3
Copyright ©2000, 2001, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.

Page generated in 0.0658 seconds (89.71% PHP - 10.29% MySQL) with 31 queries
Page Loading Time:

Support Apolyton: Amazon USA | Amazon UK | Amazon DE | Amazon FR |
Support Apolyton and get FREE PLUS, Buy from Chips&Bits: Galactic Civilizations | Galactic Civilizations: Deluxe Edition | Call to Power 2 | Civilization: The Boardgame | GURPS/ Alpha Centauri | Alpha Centauri | Civilization IV | Civilization III: Complete |


Front Page | Civilization IV | Civilization III | Civilization II | Call to Power II | Alpha Centauri | Master of Orion III
Rise of Nations | Galactic Civilizations | Galactic Civilizations II | Misc
Alt.Civs | Civ I | C:CtP I | About | News | Directory | Apolyton Store | Forums | Chat | Columns | Interviews | Newsletter
Scenario League | CSC | Clash of Civs | Spanish Site | CtP Maps | Cradle of Civ | WesW's Ctp1/2 Site | Civ3 Haven

apolyton.net | apolyton.com | civilization2.net | civilization3.net | civilization4.net | civilizationiv.info | calltopower.net | galciv.net | galciv2.net | moo3.net