 |
|  |
 |
|
Last Conformist
|
 |
of Calakmul
Jul 2003 time: 06:19
|
|
That people with foreign background face a disadvantage in the job market is pretty much beyond dispute. Racism aside, a foreign name is a tolerable proxy for sub-par language skills, so it shouldn't be surprising if an employer, faced with two applications identical beyond from one being from a Svensson and one from a Samir, choses the former.
As for companies hiring whomever they get, it simply doesn't work that way with the kind of unemployment figures we've got. Except for some qualified categories (medical doctors, eg), employers can generally pick and chose.
(In a bizarre counterexample, I got my unqualified job from the hiring guy calling me and asking me if I wanted a job. I didn't, so he offered me another position, which I took.)
|
|
|  |
 |
|
OzzyKP
|
 |
Rockville, MD
Oct 1999 time: 00:19
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Carolus Rex
Well... I thought (hoped) my post would reveal that not everyone agrees with that blogger's views...
Homogeneity and Scandinavia (Sweden, Norway, Denmark) is interesting... I think Finland and Iceland are the most homogeneous by far of the nordic countries...
Despite 1 of 10 being born abroad, my impression is that Sweden is still quite homogeneous... Of course, it's not like in the 1950s and 1960s, but...
Still, the concept (homogeneity) is strange to say the least... It implies that there is some genuine, true, one and only ethnic group that everyone else stems from (at least if you're a "real" swede)... A common (mis)conception among neo-nazis and racists, I believe...
Carolus |
Heh, I confess I didn't read your long post (as you predicted), but yea, I agree. And by homogeneity I don't mean really one's blood line, I know how there really isn't, and never has been one pure race of ANY people except totally isolated tribes. Mixing is the norm not the exception. But I meant more in terms of culture, nationality, language, skin-color (superficial, I know, but its something).
But yea, in the US we are rapidly approaching a world where white Americans will be less than 50% of the total. There will be no "majority". meh, I'm not really worried about it.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Carolus Rex
|
|
Sweden
Jan 1970 time: 06:19
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Last Conformist
That people with foreign background face a disadvantage in the job market is pretty much beyond dispute. Racism aside, a foreign name is a tolerable proxy for sub-par language skills, so it shouldn't be surprising if an employer, faced with two applications identical beyond from one being from a Svensson and one from a Samir, choses the former.
|
True.
But still, it's a disturbing fact that many bus drivers, taxi drivers, cleaning persons, fast food staff, factory workers and people in other low status professions are i) immigrants and ii) often have very high skills and education and were engineers, doctors, librarians etc in their home countries.
Whether that depends on poor integration efforts on their part or on some systematic flaw in swedish integration policies or on racism or on a mix of all of the above... It's still a waste of human capital...
Carolus
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Carolus Rex
|
|
Sweden
Jan 1970 time: 06:19
|
|
quote: Originally posted by OzzyKP
And by homogeneity I don't mean really one's blood line, I know how there really isn't, and never has been one pure race of ANY people except totally isolated tribes. Mixing is the norm not the exception. But I meant more in terms of culture, nationality, language, skin-color (superficial, I know, but its something).
|
I see. Well, I think for sure that Sweden was more homogeneous in those terms back in the 1950s, 1960s, and even in the early 1970s. But that society was so, so closed and conformist relative to the one today... I sure wouldn't enjoy living in it!
For example, when TV had its break-through in the 1950s there was only one, state-controlled channel... Everyone watched (were fed?) the same programs at the same time...
People surely all talked about the same single friday night show during coffe-breaks at work the monday after... Homogeneous? Probably... Lack of diversity and dangerously conformist? Most definitely!
Where I used to live there was a fast food place, the owner is palestinian and came to Sweden in the 1960s with 5 US dollars in his pocket... He told me that Sweden was so different back then...
For example, to buy olive oil you had to go to Apoteket; it wasn't available in the shops! (In Sweden the state has a monopoly on selling medicine. Apoteket is the name of the shops were you can buy it; we don't have private drug shops...)
That being said, there have always been foreign influences in every country... I recently read that the english word f-u-c-k is actually of nordic origin! Supposedly, the vikings who settled in England and served in the Kings' courts brought it with them... In ancient nordic languages it meant "to move back and forth"... I don't think english hooligans are the poorer for it when they "argue" with the referees... 
quote: Originally posted by OzzyKP
But yea, in the US we are rapidly approaching a world where white Americans will be less than 50% of the total. There will be no "majority". meh, I'm not really worried about it.
|
Neither am I.
Carolus
Last edited by Carolus Rex on 24-07-2005 at 16:22
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Carolus Rex
|
|
Sweden
Jan 1970 time: 06:19
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Winston
Carolus,
I'd just like to point out that when I thought of this thread and bumped it, I had the Weekly Standard article A Swedish Dilemma in mind as being possibly of interest to you, not the blogger's ramblings linked in Stefu's OP.
|
Ok, I'll check it out.
Carolus
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Last Conformist
|
 |
of Calakmul
Jul 2003 time: 06:19
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Winston
Carolus,
I'd just like to point out that when I thought of this thread and bumped it, I had the Weekly Standard article A Swedish Dilemma in mind as being possibly of interest to you, not the blogger's ramblings linked in Stefu's OP. Which I only glanced at myself. |
That's indeed an interesting piece.
I'm, incidentally, surprised to learn that Metro is Swedish. Let's kick them out.
quote: Also, I believe we established that Sweden at this time has about 2 million foreign born and descendants, not 1 million. Out of a total pop. of 9 million, this is what makes you "special", and this whole topic worthy of discussion. Well, that and the fact that your decision makers seem very determined to be fast asleep in the face of the problems emerging from this rampant immigration. |
Having different ideas from you on how something is to be solved does not constitute a determination to be fast asleep.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Last Conformist
|
 |
of Calakmul
Jul 2003 time: 06:19
|
|
An excerpt from Winston's article:
quote: An entire revisionist history of the past hundred years of Swedish economics and politics is beginning to emerge from the work of Norberg and others. Sweden misjudged its strengths. Chief among these was that, for most of the last century, Sweden was the least protectionist country in the world. Private companies had to fend for themselves, without subsidies or tariffs. The result was an entrepreneurial energy unequalled anywhere. Saab cars ran, and Electrolux vacuum cleaners whined, on all continents. This extraordinary business acumen persists today in Ikea, Absolut vodka, H&M retailers, and the Metro newspapers that are the most widely circulated in the world. |
I'm not sufficiently into economical history really evaluate this "revisionist history", but one of their examples is weird - Saab's always been firmly in bed with the gov't - and one should be a priori suspicious when a right-wing think-tank presents a historical narrative so eminently useful for right-wingers.
quote: "Many of us," says Masoud Kamali, an Iranian-born professor of ethnic studies at the University of Uppsala, "saw Sweden as the homeland of tolerance, solidarity, and democracy, based on the image of Sweden abroad." | That's the problem with propaganda - people might believe you.
quote: Sweden has actually implemented two large pieces of George W. Bush's agenda, at which Americans have thus far balked: (partially) privatized social security and (thoroughly) voucherized schools. Persson has continued these programs. | Given what's been happening in Swedish schools during the last couple decades, I can only conclude I've misunderstood what school vouchers are. Someone enlighten me?
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
BlackCat
|
|
Hadn't forgot you, and no, I haven't been inside a bottle since last - my goddaughter became 11 and my sister would have killed me if I had stayed away 
quote: Originally posted by Carolus Rex
Well... What to say, what to say?
First, I haven't (yet) read all the nonsense that blogger is writing...
I just find this fear of Islam and "Islamisation" truly ridiculous... Citing what fundamentalists and zealots crave in response to someone "backtalking" their prophet and religion as a general tendency about how muslims think or behave... 
The guy should read Islam A Short History by Karen Armstrong or a couple of Bernard Lewis' (former Princeton professor IIRC) books on the subject... The former is an informative description of its history; Lewis' (more recent) books deal with current affairs and problematise more...
|
Quite right - not many danes give a sh!t for what Glistup has said - Unless I'm wrong he's one more time in jail for saying stupid things . About those books, don't expect such persons to read something that will prove them false.
quote:
Fundamentalist groups in power (ab)using religious sources to justify and implement their political/religious agenda i) is nothing new ii) is not unique for islam and iii) does not necessarily represent the will of most people in that country in general...
|
That is right, but as history also has proven, such people doesn't need the support of a majority of the population to try to implement their ideas. I find it pretty stupid to ignore such things - especially it it's done in the holy name of multiculturalism.
quote:
I've met 3 muslims that I've got to know pretty well. The first was in the PhD program; he was (is) a kurd that escaped from Iran... Yes, I had problems with quite a lot of his views (womens' role, homosexuality, and even masturbation, which was a sin to him... )...
To me he was disturbingly conservative and unforgiving (he once told me he would denounce his own children if they turned out to be homosexual )... We still got along, often discussed our differences, and shot a lot of pool together...
Value-wise we didn't have much in common and he wasn't a close friend, but we can still live together in the same country... Only a hundred years ago those same values permeated Sweden, and I'm pretty sure there were not many muslims here then... People and societies evolve, and they will continue to do so given the chance... If it's not the current generation, it'll be the next and so on...
The two other muslims I know are guys I met in Geneva. We lived in the same dorm... One is from Marocco and also has some (to me) dubious views on womens' sexuality... Also, he doesn't drink alcohol (which to a nordic person is quite suspect... ). He is a really funny guy, though, with a lot of humour and charm... The ladies really liked him! 
The other is from Turkey and is one of the nicest persons I've ever met... To my surprise (and against my prejudices), he's completely "european"... Ok, he didn't eat during the day when it was Ramadam, but that was only to keep our north-african friend company during the night... Plus, he drank alcohol... BTW, the three of us also shot some pool together... Seriously, those guys were (are) fun company!
On the other hand, at the same dorm there was this swiss guy... Almost as conservative as my Iranian friend in the PhD program (he's from one of the most conservative cantons in Switzerland...)... He'd been in Sweden and studied a year, spoke swedish impressively well...
We had almost nothing in common and even less to say to each other... IMO he was a self-righteous and introvert person with no curiousity whatsoever about new phenomena in society... All he wanted was "things" to go back like they "used to be"... We never shot pool together...
Bottom-line: religion or race is not an issue as long as you can shoot a lot of pool together! 
|
Short story - if you can play pool, you can talk reasonable with even the weirdest persons. Whatch out - I play a mean skomar .
quote:
It is true that swedish integration policy has failed to some extent... I think the obvious symptom is the disproportional high unemployment rates among immigrants (and the ghetto-like areas we see in, for example, Malmö)... I think there are many reasons for this:
i) the language
Swedish isn't a global language (duh!) and admittedly difficult to learn. Without it, it's difficult to enter the (qualified) labour market
|
Neither is danish, but I guess that a scandinav settling in pakistan or turkey would have simliar problems. Though, I don't buy this generalization - The guy that solves my PC problems fits the descritpion well - dark skinned, brown eye, has the name Imad and don't speak fluid danish - gives some funny situations where we have to talk in "circles" to clarify problem and solution.
quote:
ii) the different economic conditions today
The time from the end of World War II until the late 1960s/early 1970's is known as the Golden Age. The economy was up, unemployment was low and there was excess demand for labour, satisfied by a "labour force immigrant wave" (mainly Yugoslavians and Finns).
Heck, you just presented yourself at the factory gates (or office doors) asking for a job and you were in! Today, the situation is quite different. Even for native Swedes with academic degrees, the labour market is a harsh mistress... Unemployment is (IIRC) about 8 percent (or around there somewhere), a record high for a country used to 2-3 percent...
iii) racism
Investigating journalists have applied for jobs using their real (foreign) names in one application for a job and using (made up) typical swedish names in another (for the same job; also when applying for different jobs). Yes, you guessed it: it was far more likely that they got contacted when they claimed to be a Svensson rather than an Al-Jahab...
|
Hasn't that always been the case ? The "misfits" have always suffered when economics is low. Speaking the wrong dialect of the common language would be enough. The difference is that you now can place labels such as foreign origin, another religion etc and suddently it is called persecution of people.
quote:
Devising and implementing "good" policies to help people adapt to a new society with a completely different set of values is tricky business... So far, Sweden hasn't risen to the challenge... Narrow-mindedness will not make it any easier...
Carolus |
Well, for me, it seems that the real narrowmindedness that are expressed currently in Sweden is that if you dare to say that there are a problem, then you automaticaly is labelled as a racist. Unless you get rid of this PC, you never get closer to solutions (no, there is not one solution that solves all).
The danish debate can sometimes be rather harsh, people even be drawn into court and sometimes sentenced, but the difference is that there is a debate, an the best part of it is that the immigrants are participating - and seriously thet are just as divided as native danes - their views goes from "it's societys fault" to Glistrup is right (yeah, even immigrants can be stupid ).
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:19. Apolyton Time is 00:19. |
top of page
|
|
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|