18-09-2000 10:22									#1
	Free cities Support Apolyton

When you play civ, if you get a free city, do you usually think it a sign of other civs or is it merely a free city?

------------------
Do you wish to trade blows or goods? I offer both.

	18-09-2000 17:32									#2
	Full PM-box? Change here!

My experience is that finding an advanced tribe in one of your first 6-7 huts is usually associated with a very bad starting position - an island, bad terrain, proximate neighbours (usually all three).

The city is almost always close to a special resource, but annoyingly misplaced for the patterns of four specials.

	18-09-2000 18:50									#3
	Remove this text

To me, it's a sure sign that in four or five moves the barbs are going to show up and take it. So you have to send a unit all the way to that city to defend it, or rush build a unit. Mostly, though, I think they're just free cities, unless it's early in the game. The bad side of getting them, from my experience, is that they're usually halfway across the world and I need the trade route. The good side is that sometimes you get improvements in them you don't have to build--temples, markets, even a library if you're lucky. I've yet to come across a free city that has walls, though.

	18-09-2000 20:19									#4
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations

If I understand the initial question properly... it's just a free city and has nothing to do with whether other civs are around or not.

If I was given the choice between a free city or Wandering Tribe, I would always want the wandering tribe. As pointed out, it's amazing how a free city ALWAYS seems to just miss the key special resources
A wandering tribe is non supported, and can be used to place a city on a nearby super location.

In SP games, free cities usually bother me. I play a more perfectionest style and really don't need the random cities. Each city I place is well planned. I usually keep my cities to the minimum depending on the size of the world, and what I'm trying to accomplish.

However, in MP games... GIVE ME THE FREE CITIES. I don't care were they are located, or if they have missed the specials. MP games are a race to expand.
A free city (even in a terrible location) early in the game can have an exponential effect on your growth.
To get a free city in the first 1000 years can pay big dividends down the road, while also help establishing territory early in the game.

	18-09-2000 23:22									#6
	Support Apolyton, pre-order Civilization IV

Chainsaw - just because you produce a settler from a free city doesn't make it a nomad. When the settler is built, if the closest city belongs to you, the settler will be supported from that city.

	18-09-2000 23:24									#7
	Suffering from ads?

Yeah Chainsaw... In SP games, I usually end up disbanding "free" cities so I can move it to where it should be. Against the AI, the delay doesn't hurt, and you will do better in the long run.

In MP games... I just go with the flow and do what I can with the new city. I have never disbanded one, because all cities are important in MP, even if they suck Now, I have used them as bait before...

	19-09-2000 03:39									#8
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations: Deluxe Edition

DaveV:
Right. My v2.42 update isn´t very old. Playing v1.02 you got a NONE settler, if the disbanded city wasn´t too near a friendely city (Playing 1.02 you also could build NONE units in some cities. And hime yor whole army there ).

Ming: I´m still desperately trying to get my hands on MPGE...

	19-09-2000 04:20									#9
	Support Apolyton, buy GURPS/ Alpha Centauri

Yes - in good old version 1.07, the 128th city (and onwards) started to produce NON units. You were never sleazing seriously until you reached it!
-------------
SG (2)

	19-09-2000 23:24									#12
	Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

i agree that if you are behind in population you stand a higher chance of getting a free city or nomad. However this does't explain the free city from your first hut, which from what i have read seems to be huge in MP games.

Also, what is the deal with receiving three free cities in a row? i popped three huts in one turn on a river bed and got three free cities with only slightly overlapping radius's

	19-09-2000 23:26									#13
	Lose 30 kilos (of popups)

In my opinion, free cities do mostly suck. There are always barbs nearby, and most of the time, they end up taking the undefended city the turn after I get it. They always miss the specials, and their locations are generally very poor. They tend to turn up far from the rest of my civ. The last few times I've gotten a free city, there have been too many citizens to support - I'd find a size four city from a hut, but there would be no grassland or food specials. So every turn I'd have to hear about the poor starving citizens in the lame city I didn't want in the first place. A wandering tribe is clearly way better to find, but I almost never seem to get them...

	20-09-2000 02:10									#16
	Increase Your PM Length

DaveV, i didn't know you could do that

I view anything but the dreaded Warrior Code and barbarians as a plus from huts, but there is no doubt in my mind that random cities are often poorly placed.
Disbanding hopefully far enough away from my empire to have "none" status is ideal and then BAM! put the city where it would normally be placed.

I think this is done to guide you into making contact with other civs sooner than perhaps one normally would. Some games i do not pick up Horseback Riding until late, somewhat hampering my exploration if i don't get enough fast units or any for that matter

------------------
Do you wish to trade blows or goods? I offer both.

	20-09-2000 06:16									#18
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations

Yeah, it's amazing how that advanced civ is just one or two squares away from the prefect spot. Anyway, I disband it too and build another where I wish it had been. What gets hard is when it's got the bunch of improvements somebody mentioned - sell them or make do with the bad location? And I think even worse, you continue exploring and discover new units attached to the city you're in the process of disbanding - again, keep it and make do, hustle 'em back and disband, or just watch them disappear? ... Oh, well ....

	20-09-2000 13:36									#20
	Put an end to popups!

BlackJack:

If the city´s location is OK for starting a colonization of the area you´ve found the city, sell everything you don´t need. (I often find size three cities with e.g. granary, temple and marketplace.)
Otherwise, sell everything. That way, you can by off that disbanding settler for that money and you even get a surplus.

	20-09-2000 18:21									#21
	Browse Apolyton AD-FREE

Beyond the chances of getting a free city in a hut, I've always wondered what the chances are of getting a more "developed" city. Sometimes it seems that early in the game you might get a city with a temple and marketplace, and later in the game--when you're hitting the last of the huts--you get one with more improvements. I think I've hit a couple--mind you, out of hundreds of games--where the city had a library or the city was building an aqueduct. I might be wrong about that. Has anybody gotten a lot of improvements in a free city, or strange combinations of improvements?

	20-09-2000 20:38									#23
	Support Apolyton, buy GURPS/ Alpha Centauri

Yeah SCG, I just read that topic thread you pointed out, thanks. I swear that later in the game--say when I'm into building airports and such--that I've run across a size 6 or 8 city with lots of improvements and a defender in it, at least once in a blue moon. Maybe it's the same programming in the game that causes the AI to keep up with you on techs and wonders. It doesn't happen enough in my games to test it out, but next time I find one I'll report it.

	20-09-2000 22:05									#25
	Suffering from ads?

is there a basis for cities with improvements? I have received cites with temples , markets and libraries. Never knew why or how, they must have been in awe of my glorious empire

	21-09-2000 03:00									#27
	Enter the AD-FREE zone

The hut pattern will only NOT place a hut on the map if the square is an ocean square. It will place them on the coast. (I've seen it millions of times)

In addition, as long as the square on the shore is plains or grasslands, you can get an advanced tribe from it (I've seen that thousands of times)

	22-09-2000 03:56									#28
	Put an end to popups!

I've always kept the free City, producing Settlers until I have more than enough Cites to control the area. I can usually keep the city at size 2 or 3 while doing this, and then I just quick build the last two Settlers from that City disbanding it. With just a little cost every so often to build the settler at just the right time, you can populate a new continent in no time.

	22-09-2000 12:34									#29
	Put an end to popups!

bpayne1, that is correct. It is a great way to start a new front if your rival is there. Nothing like a chokepoint or defensive barrier to keep the "savages" out whilst you colonize the area and build backwards to connect the homeland ; even if the enemy isn't there, its a good strat though. You can never have too much land.

I am surprised that players don't regard far off cities, ie one's on the other side of your continent or ones on another island as signs of a rival civ nearby. Oh well, maybe i am reading WAY TOO much into civ these days

------------------
Do you wish to trade blows or goods? I offer both.

	24-09-2000 00:24									#30
	Got spare money?

I sometime send a diplomat on a ship to pick of these coast huts. If you get barbs the dip just jump back on the ship with the second turn.