 |
|
eric789
|
|
HazieDaVampire
quote: is the Fact that its actualy spelt Corea, but invaded Japanese made them change it to a K? |
I don't know and nothing is proved yet. I know once Europe called Korea, as Coree and Corea is still used by countries of Latin origin but there is no evidence that the Japanese actually changed the spelling but pure speculation. The origianl spelling was "Coree" but no one knows why it became "Korea".
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Ribannah
|
 |
The Netherlands, Embassy of the Iroquois Confederacy
Aug 2000 time: 06:15
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Q Cubed
in north america, no tribe held as much sway as the aztecs did; nor would any have been able to form any sort of political network comparable to the aztecs. the iroquoi tried, but started far too late to truly develop a strong nation. |
Funny. The League came into being in 1451 AD, built a large empire and stayed in good shape until they were divided over Handsome Lake's teachings and the American war of independence. They had a fully functioning democratic confederacy which lasted a whole lot longer than the Aztecs' cruel rule.
When it comes to political networks, I'd also rate the Sioux, Apache, Cherokee, Kiowa and several other tribes higher than the Aztecs and their offspring the Comanche.
Other than being in power for a short while, until it succumbed to the well-justified uprising, the Aztec rule produced nothing remarkable. I don't see how that can be compared to either Korea or the Iroquois.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
King of Rasslin
|
|
"You said that the Aztecs represent the Latin-American civs, the Hispanic civs, which is different from the Aztec one. That's one very dangerous claim to make.. "
That isn't true. Aztecs and Mexicans are the same, except a few Mexicans might have a small amount of Spanish blood in them. I consider myself white even though I might have an American Indian great-great-great-great grandmother.
However, the culture of the Aztecs (human sacrifice, cannibalism, gross stuff like that) is very different from the Spanish (bull fighting, nude beaches, and other pleasant things). The race is the same, but they have been civilized by the Spanish influence.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
eric789
|
|
King of Rasslin
quote: That isn't true. Aztecs and Mexicans are the same, except a few Mexicans might have a small amount of Spanish blood in them. I consider myself white even though I might have an American Indian great-great-great-great grandmother. |
60% of Mestizos, mixed blood of the Spanish and the native,10% of Caucasians and 30% of the native descents form the Mexcian population. 70% of the Mexicans carry the Spanish and other European blood.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
yellfromhell
|
 |
Montevideo, Uruguay
Jun 2002 time: 05:15
|
|
Q-Cubed,
I admit my little knowledge about Korea took me to think the Aztecs deserve better than Korea to have representation in civ3. That problem is solved, you and Eric won, I lost.
I accept we can continue discussing in a new thread were if Korea or Mexico deserve better to have representation in civ3.
I congratulate you for understanding that the method you employed to argue about economic power is similar to the one I wrongly used to argue about militaristic power and I accept you didnt use hypoteticals (but, I still think you could be suggesting one); eventhough you still say the mexican economic growth is a direct effect of the NAFTA suscription (and, for me, that is doubtfull; we cant know that).
I believe I`ve never attacked Korea. Perhaps I did, but please know for sure that I had no intention to do so.
Hugs,
Yellfromhell.
-------------------------------------------
Eric,
Except for the last paragraph, everything I said to Q-Cubed goes for you. I accept you were right in appointing my dangerous assumptions.
I still do not accept errors in this things:
a) You jumped in the discussion after I introduced Mexico in it, so "Mexico vs. Korea" was also being discussed then.
b) in the specific topic "Aztec vs. Korea" I did bring many facts to support my point of view. The problem was not the lack of facts, but that Q-Cubed brought Koreas more impressive facts to the table. Therefore, my only error was my lack of knowledge about Korea.
c) there are lots of more facts to bring about the Aztec civilization, but from know on I´ll show them sure that they havent enough weight to be opposed to Koreas ones.
d) I would have mentioned spanish influence in Mexico anyway, no matter if you entered in the discussion or not, because I dont feel humiliation when recognizing the other part has the reason. As a counterattack, I would have probably argued about USAs support to South Korea, a kind of support that Mexico does not recibe (because Mexico is not involved in any issue related to USAs war against communism)
I congratulate you for recognizing you were wrong when you ironically asked "Does Mexico carries a single tradition of the Aztec?".
I hope this make clear my actual position.
Hugs
Yellfromhell
Last edited by yellfromhell on 21-07-2002 at 21:35
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Lord Merciless
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Ribannah
Funny. The League came into being in 1451 AD, built a large empire and stayed in good shape until they were divided over Handsome Lake's teachings and the American war of independence. They had a fully functioning democratic confederacy which lasted a whole lot longer than the Aztecs' cruel rule.
When it comes to political networks, I'd also rate the Sioux, Apache, Cherokee, Kiowa and several other tribes higher than the Aztecs and their offspring the Comanche.
Other than being in power for a short while, until it succumbed to the well-justified uprising, the Aztec rule produced nothing remarkable. I don't see how that can be compared to either Korea or the Iroquois. |
The Aztec capital Tenochtitlan alone would put all achievements made by Iroquois, Sioux, and other North American tribes to shame. The city itself even put Spaniards in astonishment.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
yellfromhell
|
 |
Montevideo, Uruguay
Jun 2002 time: 05:15
|
|
Ribannah,
[quote]:
"Other than being in power for a short while, until it succumbed to the well-justified uprising, the Aztec rule produced nothing remarkable. I don't see how that can be compared to either Korea or the Iroquois".
I accept thay cant be compared to Korea. I`ll learn more about the Iroquois and talk later about your affirmation.
But I can surely say the Aztecs did a lot of remarkable thing, and therefore I think you are wrong. The cruelty of the Aztec empire can also be discussed: their cannibalism and sacrifices where not done with any feeling of cruelty, but with fear of the gods. Many times common people offered themselves to be sacrificed as a gift to the gods, and that was seens as an honour. I understand that, for us, It looks cruel.
Hugs,
Yellfromhell
|
|
|  |
 |
|
King of Rasslin
|
|
We just allow the Indians to make casinos and take the money from stupid people anyway. It still won't repay the damage we did, though. But you do have to consider that we are the greatest country ever, and they are lucky to be living here. We really don't owe them as much as they want, but Uruguay is another story. I have only heard about poverty in South American countries, but you must be very wealthy if you own a computer.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Aro
|
 |
Ipanema
Jul 2002 time: 02:15
|
|
Yellfromhell:
In Brazil, we feel the same. And we have some tribes.
King of Rasslin:
I can't wait to know what you have to say about jewish people. Or palestinians, arabs in general, refugees from Central Europe, afghans, indians (from India!) Did I forgot someone? You seems to have that little nice words about everybody: latino-americans, asians, afro-americans, native americans, african people... (including "stupid people")!
I can't wait. 
Oh, si... Yellfromhell owns a computer, and is from medium class. Me too.
IMNSHO, you realy need to learn a little more about Brazil, Uruguay, Argentina, Chile... We are very interesting! Some of our richest people could buy a lot of computers, you know 
BTW, you could learn more about YOUR country, too. Read the newspapers, especially the economic news. Or, if you don't read newspapers, too... Try the CNN!
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Aro
|
 |
Ipanema
Jul 2002 time: 02:15
|
|
I see two channels (CNN International, I don’t have BBC, and a brazilian news network on cable, Globo News), and read four newspapers almost every day, due to my job. It's necessary to find something close to the truth... I avoid this "smart graphics", too, and I have all your motives and one more to do this: for a long time (long to me: two months) I worked in a newspaper making that damn info graphics. Argh!!! 
In my last post, I was trying to be sarcastic, but my english don't help... As a matter of fact, most of the press can be insulting to intelligence. We are in an electoral period here in Brazil, and some days the papers make me really mad. Because I know they are not telling the truth, I'm a journalist too…
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Lord Merciless
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Ribannah
You have to distinguish between the city Tenochtitlan and the Aztecs. The city is much older and has indeed a rich history. |
You mean that Aztecs came in as conquerors and simply inherited what their predecessors had? If that's the case, then who can represent Middle American civilization better than the Aztecs? The Olmecs who died out long time ago, the nameless people who build Teotihuacan and Tula, or the Tlaxcalans who helped Spanish crush the Aztecs?
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Aro
|
 |
Ipanema
Jul 2002 time: 02:15
|
|
King of Rasslin,
Here in Brazil we call them... people! It's very simple, try it! As said by Albert Einstein, we all belong to the human race...
BTW, I'm not politically correct, I can't. I'm a political cartoonist, and my duty is smash everyone who deserves. And I do this with nothing but my pencil!!! (In fact, I draw with my Wacom Pen). AND "black people" are not black. Is very difficult even to scientists find something really black. Even astronomical black holes have some radiation leaking from it.
So, should I call you Pink? Because you’re not white (did you know that?), unless you are dead, with no blood in your body.
In resume: all of us are "colored" people... You too, pale face! 
I don't know if this post can be considered as spam, but discussions about this matter can help and improve everyone. And, maybe, make the world a little better.
Sorry, Yin26 and Q cubed… 
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Lord Merciless
|
|
I must remind everyone that Indians are "Whites", Arabs also qualify as "Whites. Linguistically speaking, Indian languages are closer to West European ones than either Finnish or Hungarian.
Yeah, I guessed somehow that Ribannah confused Tenochtitlan with Teotihuacan.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
King of Rasslin
|
|
People from America are Indians.
People from India are Hindus.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Lord Merciless
|
|
quote: Originally posted by King of Rasslin
People from America are Indians.
People from India are Hindus. |
Indians are always from India. That poor Columbus thought he found India, so he named the people he encountered "Indians". He failed to realize that he had discovered a whole new continent, and refused to do so until his death.
As already pointed out by Q-Qubed, Hindus only represents a religious groups among Indians. There are at least 170 million Indian Muslims, making India the country with second most Muslim population.
I never refer to American "Indians" as Indians. Either I use the tribe names directly, or I call them Native Americans.
Aro, can you show us some of the politcal cartoons you drew?
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:15. Apolyton Time is 00:15. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|