 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Imran Siddiqui

|
 |
The Potterverse
Jan 1970 time: 00:23
|
|
quote: Your statement was that someone doing somehting to feel good is greedy, because you think that feeling good is not part of basic human needs. i think you are wrong there. Wanting to feel good is normal, and hence, not excessive, thus it can't be 'greedy' at all. |
I think you are wrong there. Doing acts of charity is to continue the 'good feeling' beyond how you normally feel good and there is greedy. You cannot say that there are somethings you cannot do 'too much' of. Even in charity, people can do too much of it, and then they are simply greedy for the benefits it confers to them.
I don't think you need to feel all good about yourself in order to live. If we go back to your state of nature, I doubt natives really ever thought that they should do charity. Therefore it was unnecessary for them and thus since it is 'excessive', greedy.
quote: Cpitalism is about the flow of capital, where the capital comes from is immaterial to what should be done with it, and what the most efficient ways of creating it are. |
Actually where the capital comes from is fairly important. The costs depend on where it arises. The slave trade wasn't cheap. It cost a lot of money. As pointed out, the people that bought the slaves LOST money. Therefore showing it was an inefficient practice and thus needing to be replaced.
quote: Just because the original thinker thinks something means nothing, ask Marx. |
Of course it means something! Marxism is defined by Marx. True Communism is Marx and Engles. Everything else are variations on the basic theme.
quote: Man didn't decide to farm. Man didn't decide to become civilized. |
Yes he did. He weighed, in a cost-benefit analysis, if he should continuing doing what he has been doing or adapt. He adapted.
quote: That gold and silver came into spain, eneded in flanders and the netherlands. Spain speant all its money on frivilous things, like wars. Think of Spain as someone who won the lottery and spent it al away. that money doesn't disappear, it goes to the merchants and others there to meet the needs of spain. And since that money, unlike lottery money, ddn't come out of the pool of capital already around, but come from 'thin air', all the better! |
Wrong. Money out of 'thin air' is the worst. It is extremely inflationary wiping out any benefits accrued by it. The inflation killed any gains the Spaniards made off it.
quote: How I feed myself is a question of economics now, because it has been made an issue of economics, not because it is naturally. I have never seen a book on the economics of the aborigenes, yet they eat. |
Because the economics of the aborigenes is boringly simple. It's a communal economic system. The question of eating is always an economic question. A question of weighing costs and benefits of certain actions.
Roland already (basically) addressed the point about the New World changing Europe's views, so I'll just contend with this:
quote: In fact, the huge boom in population was probably vital to the huge growth of capitalism (more workers, more consumers) |
BS. Capitalism does not need a huge amount of workers. If there are not a great amount of workers, capitalism adapts the economy to capital intensive technologies. Why do you think Europe went to that mode of production? Because compared to India, China, etc, they were severly underpopulated. Of course, capitalism tends to create a boom, because first, medicines and the technology of sanitation (it doesn't suffice to simply put a hole in the ground) lower the death rate, and the birth rate continues to remain high. Eventually that growth stabilizes because capitalism tends to reduce family size (cost of children becomes relatively much higher). A larger population isn't needed for capitalism and never was. Capitalism did fairly ok in places that didn't have a 'boom'.
|
|
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:23. Apolyton Time is 00:23. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|