06-01-2005 00:07									#211
	Support Apolyton

HL1 was linear.

Good thing too.......replay value from FPS games comes from it being fun to play through again, not doing different things (though the RPG/FPS hybrids usually make a small attempt). The games in this genre are usually short enough as it is.

	10-01-2005 19:07									#212
	Support Apolyton or Terrorists Win

Well, I for one played HL2 twice, was bored and went back to Far Cry, which is simply terrific in comparison to either Doom 3 or HL2. Far Cry has much better AI than either Doom 3 or HL2, and is certainly not linear. With linear games, the game plays exactly the same each time. With non linear games, each game is different to a degree.

	10-01-2005 21:11									#213
	Support Apolyton

I still want FPS games to have good action, something that both HL2 and Doom3 had in excess, instead of freedom of action. That's what RPGs are for. Heck, that's what Civ is for. Whatever a FPS game might try to do, it will still never be as replayable as Civ, so sod it.

	10-01-2005 23:57									#214
	Suffering from ads?

quote: Originally posted by Ned Far Cry has much better AI than either Doom 3 or HL2, and is certainly not linear.

I agree it is more linear than HL, and a good game. I think though that it's quality lies in gameplay, not the slight non-linearity. I'd replay it for that even if the small non-linearity disappeared.

	11-01-2005 00:10									#215
	Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

Solver, in a way, I agree about Civ. But the reason is that each Civ game is different to a degree because the map is variable. The maps in both Doom 3 and HL2 are not variable. Neither are they in Far Cry -- but they start with such wide openesses as to inherently allow different approaches to solving a problem.

But still, the AI in Far Cry is the best I've seen. The AI in Vietcong was also very very good.

	11-01-2005 00:20									#216
	Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

I just take being a Civ player as an advantage when playing FPS. If I'm a fan of Civ, the most replayable game, why should I feel bothered if FPS games I play aren't that replayable? I shouldn't.

I like it how with other games, you can often "finish" it, while with Civ, you don't really.

	11-01-2005 02:13									#217
	Full PM-box? Change here!

I downloaded the HL2 demo last night. All I have to say is wow. Its the best looking game I ever saw. And it runs fine at 1280x 1024. But I'm somewhat confused. In the demo, you have two levels, the intro and the "We aren't going to Ravenloft". How do the aliens from HL returned to earth? Do they work for the Combine? Please, feel free not to answer if there's a spoiler. I'll probably get this game...

	11-01-2005 02:22									#218
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations

It's never explicitly said in the game, but there are certain things in the game world that allow you to deduce most of what's taken place. I posted a link earlier in this thread to a great web page where someone had compiled all the snippets of information and had finished the gaps in the story with some credulous speculation based on that information.

	11-01-2005 02:40									#219
	Support Apolyton, buy Civilization: The Boardgame

Yeah, there are some good sites with speculation. I'll post some info snippets, but basically, if you pay attention, you can deduce most yourself.

Why headcrabs and zombies:

spoiler(highlight to read): Some headcrabs were left on Earth after HL1. Combine took them and genetically modified to create new version - the fast and black crabs. Crabs are loaded onto shells and fired into areas that resist often.

	11-01-2005 02:46									#220
	Enter the AD-FREE zone

Actually,

spoiler(highlight to read): AFAI understand, the bulk of the zombie creatures were transported on Earth accidentally in the Portal Storms, a series of interdimensional breaches which took place because of the Black Mesa Incident; either as a natural disaster or because the Combine triggered them once the Black Mesa experiment had attracted their attention.

	11-01-2005 02:54									#221
	Inflate your Upload Space

Hmm, that is not correct, I think, and I haven't seen it being suggested anywhere, either.

spoiler(highlight to read): Portal storms have apparently been initiated by the Combine. After the end of HL1, the dimensional rift between Earth & Xen was closed. However, many creatures were not obliterated. The portal storms allowed the Combine to make entrance and take over Earth. Also, look at where you see zombies in HL2. It's only the places where resistance once was, further backing up the statement that headcrabs were basically used as biological weapons by the Combine.

	11-01-2005 03:00									#222
	Increase Your PM Length

Oh, that does make much more sense.

	11-01-2005 03:07									#223
	Support Apolyton, buy Civilization: The Boardgame

Also, regarding headcrabs:

spoiler(highlight to read): In the beta, there was some thing controlled by the Combine called a "Headcrab Birthing Sack", like the one on the headcrab mother in HL1. It got cut later, but still...

	11-01-2005 03:41									#224
	Increase Your PM Length

Two Half-Life scholars debating...

	11-01-2005 03:43									#225
	Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

But I am the real guru .

	11-01-2005 03:47									#226
	Increase Your PM Length

That he is - calling me a scholar is a vast overstatement considering I've only played both games through once, and never have I engaged in multiplayer.