14-09-2001 22:58									#1
	Ask The Civ Team - 09/14/01 Edition Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

Three things:

1. They left out the Space Ship in their summary of victory conditions (under "Smells like... victory!"). I hope this was just an erroneous omission.

2. We get yet another non-answer to a question about multiplayer.

3. The Top Five Cities screen looks cool - tons of info as to how the ranking is arrived at. Then again, I always thought that looking at that screen was sort of like cheating, as it contained information that I could not obtain through any other more legitimate means (like info on cities I hadn't even discovered).

	14-09-2001 23:02									#2
	Suffering from ads?

Here is the MP question and answer:

Hello,

Let me first say that my wife and I are really looking forward to Civ 3. I introduced my wife to Civ 2 and CTP2 and she absolutely loves turn-based strategy style of game play. Not a week goes by without her asking me when Civ 3 is going to be released!

The only difficulty we've discovered with turn-based games like Civ & CTP is that multiplayer games can be slow and cumbersome, especially at later stages in the game. I've always envisioned the next great Civ-style game to introduce simultaneous turns in multiplayer. I'm sure this would introduce quite a few technical challenges though. So my question would have to be how is Civ 3 going to address this issue?

Best regards,

Joel Dudgeon


Joel,

Thanks for your email! We're working on some cool multiplayer concepts that will take a fresh approach to the challenge of making multiplayer for a turn-based game fun. We're not yet ready to give details, but stay tuned. When we have more to report, the site will be updated and our fans, as always, will be the first to know!



And the game is to be released in October ??

	14-09-2001 23:02									#3
	Get a bigger avatar today!

It only seems to summarize the brand new victory conditions; I think they assume everyone knows what the conquest and space victories are.

Also, knowing that you will be able to place resources on maps is good news for scenario makers.

	14-09-2001 23:10									#4
	Increase the size of your Attachments

quote: Originally posted by Kyller It only seems to summarize the brand new victory conditions; I think they assume everyone knows what the conquest and space victories are.

Concur.

quote: The Top Five Cities screen looks cool - tons of info as to how the ranking is arrived at. Then again, I always thought that looking at that screen was sort of like cheating, as it contained information that I could not obtain through any other more legitimate means (like info on cities I hadn't even discovered).

Yeah, I hope that you don't start seeing other cities and nations info in the Demographics before you come into contact with them. But I don't know if this will be the case or not.

quote: We get yet another non-answer to a question about multiplayer.

I know it is almost as bad as not hearing anything. Instead we keep hearing we are not ready to talk about it. Well why not? We are a month and a half from release for goodness sakes. When will you be ready to talk about it?

	14-09-2001 23:13									#5
	Support Apolyton, buy Alpha Centauri

It was amusing that the first question they chose to answer was from some doofus who never played Civ2 or SMAC and wanted to know about an inconsequential feature such as the Top 5 Cities?!? I think any one of us here could have asked a much better question (or is Firaxis purposely ignoring our questions? ).

	14-09-2001 23:13									#6
	Help yourself to an AD-FREE life

They are being extremely frustrating about MP, why even bring it up in "Ask the Developers" if they aren't going to say anything? On a good note, the very thought that they did bring it up could bode well for the future of MP

	14-09-2001 23:15									#7
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations: Deluxe Edition

Quote from the answer.

quote: As you mentioned, the traditional military (defeat all your enemies) and spaceship victories are of course back in Civ III, but we've also come up with some new ones. Here's a quick primer on them:

Spaceship victory is in the game (as said before).

	14-09-2001 23:16									#8
	Support Apolyton, buy Call to Power 2

quote: Originally posted by Steve Clark It was amusing that the first question they chose to answer was from some doofus who never played Civ2 or SMAC and wanted to know about an inconsequential feature such as the Top 5 Cities?!?

He had played SMAC, that was the whole point, the top 5 wasn't in SMAC.

Why is he a doofus for asking a question? That seems a very rude attitude to take.

	14-09-2001 23:16									#9
	Browse Apolyton AD-FREE

They integrated F8 and F11. The resulting overview showing the top 5 cities to the left and the denmographics to the right, looks finished.
No unnecesary semi-funny images, but good colors, easy readible, for the cities clear images, just as on the map with the indication of the wonders by added icons.

I hope the calculation bug for the pink nation is no longer in the game.

Having both views integrated is good, it makes it easier to check these global parameters

	14-09-2001 23:19									#10
	Support Apolyton, buy Civilization: The Boardgame

quote: Originally posted by Steve Clark It was amusing that the first question they chose to answer was from some doofus who never played Civ2 or SMAC and wanted to know about an inconsequential feature such as the Top 5 Cities?!? I think any one of us here could have asked a much better question (or is Firaxis purposely ignoring our questions? ).

the doofus did play SMAC

quote: and i sadly discovered that this feature is not available in Alpha Centauri ( i have not had the pleasure of playing Civ II, so i dont know if it is still present there).

And i noticed you can set your governors per continent, i don't think this has ever been done before. Looks like the maps will be more realistic than ever.

quote: The governors in Civ III can be instructed on what to produce as well as what NEVER to produce, and these can be set on a city-by-city basis, or on a continental or global level

	14-09-2001 23:22									#11
	Avatar Enlargement: We've got the solution

They have combined the Demographics page with Top five cities
They have always been my favorite screens in CivNet while waiting for my turn. Now I don't have to decide what screen to open. , I can open both. This opens new abilities

	14-09-2001 23:22									#12
	Enter the AD-FREE zone

quote: Originally posted by Rhysie Why is he a doofus for asking a question? That seems a very rude attitude to take.

He is not a doofus, but what I (and apparently some people) are frustrated here about is that they seem to be deliberately avoiding answers to material questions (like types and number of governments; more info on great leaders; minor wonders etc.) while answering in great detail questions which are either inconsequential or answers to which are already known/presumed.

It is irritating

	14-09-2001 23:27									#13
	Support Apolyton, buy Call to Power 2

quote: Originally posted by Martinus but what I (and apparently some people) are frustrated here about is that they seem to be deliberately avoiding answers to material questions (like types and number of governments; more info on great leaders; minor wonders etc.) while answering in great detail questions which are either inconsequential or answers to which are already known/presumed. It is irritating

But this is not the fault of those asking questions. It is the fault of the developer and the publisher. So there is no reason to call they person asking the question a doofus. Plus, I am interested in that screen although I wish they would answer the MP question but it appears they won't.

	14-09-2001 23:28									#14
	Increase the size of your Attachments

Hopefully they'll fix the part where it says "1 children" on the Top 5 Cities screen. A minor detail, but the kind of programming I expect from CTP, not Firaxis.

	14-09-2001 23:32									#15
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations

quote: Originally posted by saracen31 Hopefully they'll fix the part where it says "1 children" on the Top 5 Cities screen. A minor detail, but the kind of programming I expect from CTP, not Firaxis.

It might not be a bug, some countries do have average family sizes with less than 2 children. If it weren't for immigration then many of these countries would shrink in size, and if I remember correctly there are already some which are shrinking in population.

It does seem unlikely that a country would be shedding half of its population every generation in a game of civ though.

	14-09-2001 23:34									#16
	Support Apolyton or Terrorists Win

I meant the pluralization of 1 child. Like I said, a minor but annoying detail.

	14-09-2001 23:37									#17
	Remove this text

I just thought of another reason they would have posted Edvic's question... Don't forget that a games website is mainly a PR tool, not just there to give you information, but there to foster interest and make people think the game is going to be cool... Edvic's question is almost 50% compliment, and if people see fans complimenting the game producers and having faith in them, those people are more likely to think the game will be cool... So if you want to get your question answered on the page, load it with loads of buttery compliments!

	14-09-2001 23:37									#18
	Support Apolyton

Sorry for my name-calling. It was my reaction to someone not ever having played Civ2 getting prominent space in a limited Ask column. Martinus is correct, there were probably several good questions about AI, gameplay, customization, wonders, governments, etc. asked by us but they chose to take up valuable space on someone who not only was brown-nosing but never played Civ2 (I misread about not playing SMAC), asking about something that is not that important, imo. Just a kneejerk reaction to a frustrating read. On the other hand, the question/answer about the other ways of winning was superb.

	14-09-2001 23:38									#19
	Full PM-box? Change here!

Don't complain about what questions Firaxis answers. There is no need to. Firaxis just can't win with some of you.

The governors should be very useful in MP.

	14-09-2001 23:38									#20
	Enter the AD-FREE zone

quote: Originally posted by saracen31 I meant the pluralization of 1 child. Like I said, a minor but annoying detail.

Ah, sorry misunderstood you. You're right there I guess.

	14-09-2001 23:39									#21
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations

quote: Originally posted by Martinus He is not a doofus, but what I (and apparently some people) are frustrated here about is that they seem to be deliberately avoiding answers to material questions (like types and number of governments; more info on great leaders; minor wonders etc.) while answering in great detail questions which are either inconsequential or answers to which are already known/presumed. It is irritating

Maybe they are not releasing info on gvts, great leaders, etc because they don't want to give everything away. For obvious marketing reasons, they want to keep some details a secret so that people can discover the game when they play it. Do you really want the game "spoiled" before you play it?

	14-09-2001 23:52									#22
	Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations

quote: Originally posted by The diplomat Maybe they are not releasing info on gvts, great leaders, etc because they don't want to give everything away. For obvious marketing reasons, they want to keep some details a secret so that people can discover the game when they play it. Do you really want the game "spoiled" before you play it?

Actually it makes more sense that they aren't answering AI questions because they are hard to answer. What are you going to say to the question is the AI difficult?

Yes, it beat me yesterday.

Or to the quesiton does the AI cheat?

There just isn't a good sizable answer that you can give. But the question that is burning to be answered about MP still isn't and that isn't good PR or marketing. So no I don't think what your saying is the reason some things are being answered and not being answered.

	14-09-2001 23:57									#23
	Top 5 Cities Increase the size of your Attachments

It seems odd to me that Rome has less people than Toga Party and yet it has a larger city picture. Is this because it has more structures? Because it is the capital? Or is there some other reason?

	14-09-2001 23:57									#24
	Support Apolyton, buy Civilization III: Complete

Maybe I missed something earlier on, but I thjought there were going to be six victory conditions, one of them trade/commercial. This is not mentioned in Firaxis's reply, so I guess it's been dropped somewhere along the line.

Can anyone throw any light on this?

	15-09-2001 00:00									#25
	Support Apolyton, buy Civilization III: Complete

quote: Originally posted by tniem Actually it makes more sense that they aren't answering AI questions because they are hard to answer. What are you going to say to the question is the AI difficult? Yes, it beat me yesterday.

quote: Or to the quesiton does the AI cheat? There just isn't a good sizable answer that you can give.

You could tell all specific rules the AI have for different levels do difficulty.
The AI never cheats, it just plays after other rules.

quote: But the question that is burning to be answered about MP still isn't and that isn't good PR or marketing. So no I don't think what your saying is the reason some things are being answered and not being answered.

What is wrong with the auto-MP-answer function

	15-09-2001 00:01									#26
	Re: Top 5 Cities Support Apolyton, buy Call to Power 2

quote: Originally posted by jsw363 It seems odd to me that Rome has less people than Toga Party and yet it has a larger city picture. Is this because it has more structures? Because it is the capital? Or is there some other reason?

It's because its a capital, it was the same in civ2

	15-09-2001 00:03									#27
	Got spare money?

I'm actually a little dissapointed about the Demographics and Top 5. I was hoping for a far more extensive demographics and more items for Top 5 (i.e. military, culture).

	15-09-2001 00:05									#28
	Suffering from ads?

quote: Originally posted by Ilkuul Maybe I missed something earlier on, but I thjought there were going to be six victory conditions, one of them trade/commercial. This is not mentioned in Firaxis's reply, so I guess it's been dropped somewhere along the line. Can anyone throw any light on this?

It is not listed on the player setup screen. So if it ever was in it must have been taken out before civ3.com opened.

	15-09-2001 00:08									#29
	Support Apolyton, pre-order Civilization IV

I can think of several pointed, yet answerable AI questions. One of them would be something along the lines of how do the AI civs take advantage of the attributes assigned to them under certain conditions. For example, if a civ is expansionistic/scientific, what if runs out of room to expand (due to physical or military barriers), does it resort to becoming militaristic to continue expansion or does it just sit and stew? This gets at the key thing about AI acting and reacting according to game situations, and hopefully not on some pre-defined parameters that would be the same each game. But then again, I guess we'll find out for ourselves soon enough in the Civ3-Strategy forum.

	15-09-2001 00:13									#30
	Support Apolyton, buy GURPS/ Alpha Centauri

Thanks for the link, Gramphos; I missed that one. I think much earlier in the forums people were talking about a commercial victory, but it obviously wasn't 'official'.

By the way, that setup screen seemed to lack a Custom civ option, which is quite a blow! Does this mean you can only have custom civs in scenarios etc.?