 |
|
Caligastia
|
|
I was hoping for some kind of answer to my last post Boris...
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Caligastia
|
|
Boris-
I responded to a few things you said last week, my post is about 10 or 15 back from this one.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Wittlich

|
 |
A Wyandot lost in "The City" SF,CA
Dec 2000 time: 21:20
|
|
Here is the last debate between Boris and Caligastia...
quote:
Originally posted by Boris Godunov:
I don't think so. If people stereotype the whole based on a small minority, isn't that the fault of the stereotypers?
|
Response by Caligastia:
Partly, yes.
quote:
Posted by Boris Godunov:
How could run-of-the-mill, boring gays like myself say to the more extreme ones "You can't march, you'll make us look bad?"
|
Response by Caligastia:
They couldnt, but I still think the radical ones are doing more harm than good.
quote:
Posted by Boris Godunov:
Many of the radicals do it just to be radical. They actually resent acceptance, in a way, as they see it as depriving them of their specialness. So they're only way to be special is to be outrageous.
|
Response by Caligastia:
Pretty childish IMO.
quote:
Posted by Boris Godunov:
No, just drunken brawls and discrimination. Which would you rather have?
|
Response by Caligastia:
I didnt see any drunken brawls at the St Paddys parade, whos stereotyping now Boris?
By discrimination I assume you are talking about the fact that St Patrick's Cathedral who organise and mostly pay for the parade wont allow a gay float. I dont have a problem with this. Its their parade, so why shouldnt they have the right to say who gets to march and who doesnt? I doubt the gay pride parade would allow a gay nazi float.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Boris Godunov
|
 |
Portland, OR
Aug 2001 time: 00:20
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Wittlich
Response by Caligastia:
Partly, yes. |
Why partly? How on earth is a group that is stereotyped responsible for the negative stereotype, when we've all acknowledged that stereotype is not true for the majority?
quote:
They couldnt, but I still think the radical ones are doing more harm than good. |
I think they're just being the way they want to be. I don't see any harm in that, although I have no desire to ever be that way.
quote:
Response by Caligastia:
Pretty childish IMO. |
Yeah, I'd agree. I did say it was kinda sad, actually. Some people spend their whole lives on the fringe and can't seem to accept being accepted...
quote: Response by Caligastia:
I didnt see any drunken brawls at the St Paddys parade, whos stereotyping now Boris? |
Every year I've seen at least one after the parade, in some pub somewhere. Not in the parade, no.
quote: By discrimination I assume you are talking about the fact that St Patrick's Cathedral who organise and mostly pay for the parade wont allow a gay float. I dont have a problem with this. |
I don't like it, as it's hypocrisy on the part of Catholic leadership, considering the huge percentage of gay Catholic priests and bishops. But I'm not advocating them being forced to change their rule, just saying I find it discriminatory. It is also in direct conflict with the current Catholic teaching that homosexuals are good, fine people and that it is the sin that is the problem. The parade excludes based on who they are, not what they do.
quote: Its their parade, so why shouldnt they have the right to say who gets to march and who doesnt? |
Sure, but don't expect me to not call them on the hypocrisy of it. It's still discriminatory, whereas the Gay Pride parade doesn't discriminate against people because of who they are.
quote: I doubt the gay pride parade would allow a gay nazi float. |
Red Herring. As I said, the Catholic church officially teaches that gay people are fine, it's gay acts it doesn't like. Yet by not allowing gays to march, the church is condemning who they are. It's a slap in the face to gay Catholics everywhere.
Gay Nazis would be a different matter, as being a Nazi entails belief. No one is born a Nazi, and the exclusion would be of the ideas, not the people. And since the gay community has, by and large, repudiated the tenets of Nazism, exclusion wouldn't be akin to the two-faced hypocrisy of the St. Patrick's Day Parade at all.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Caligastia
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Boris Godunov
Why partly? How on earth is a group that is stereotyped responsible for the negative stereotype, when we've all acknowledged that stereotype is not true for the majority? |
I say partly because stereotypes dont come from nowhere. Of course gays as a group are not responsible for it, but there are plenty of them that fit the stereotype, and a few who intentionally perpetuate it.
quote:
I think they're just being the way they want to be. I don't see any harm in that, although I have no desire to ever be that way. |
I dont see any real harm in it, I have met plenty of flamers who just are that way and there is nothing they can do about it. The few who are intentionally over-flamboyant may be soiling the public image of gays somewhat though.
quote:
Every year I've seen at least one after the parade, in some pub somewhere. Not in the parade, no. |
Is this the only time you see drunken brawls in NYC? Ive seen plenty on other occasions - like new years.
quote:
I don't like it, as it's hypocrisy on the part of Catholic leadership, considering the huge percentage of gay Catholic priests and bishops. But I'm not advocating them being forced to change their rule, just saying I find it discriminatory. It is also in direct conflict with the current Catholic teaching that homosexuals are good, fine people and that it is the sin that is the problem. The parade excludes based on who they are, not what they do. |
Well its fine for you to disagree, I just support their right to do what they want with their parade.
quote:
Sure, but don't expect me to not call them on the hypocrisy of it. It's still discriminatory, whereas the Gay Pride parade doesn't discriminate against people because of who they are. |
Its obviously hypocritical then, but if they want to be hypocrites with their parade - so be it. They only hurt themselves.
quote:
Gay Nazis would be a different matter, as being a Nazi entails belief. No one is born a Nazi, and the exclusion would be of the ideas, not the people. And since the gay community has, by and large, repudiated the tenets of Nazism, exclusion wouldn't be akin to the two-faced hypocrisy of the St. Patrick's Day Parade at all. |
Well do you think a straight pride float in the gay parade wouldnt have any opposition?
|
|
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:20. Apolyton Time is 00:20. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|