Apolyton Archive  |  Preserved copy of the Apolyton Civilization Site and its forums as they stood in September 2005. Read-only; nothing here can be posted to or replied to.  |  Forum index |  About this archive |  The 1998–2001 UBB forums
Today on Apolyton WARDELL INTERVIEW PROMO A.C.S. HISTORY CHAPTER 4 GET CIV4 /w FREE PLUS! A.C.S. PHOTO GALLERY GET A.O.M. V1.1
Apolyton Civilization Forums
main| civ2| civ3| civ4| smac| ctp2| ron| moo3| galciv| galciv2| alt| about|
ApolytonPLUS | register | search | faq | new posts | pm (-/-) | upload | members
hall of fame new! | civgroups | civgroups news | interviews | the column | radio | chat | directory | news | store | PLUS
Apolyton Civilization Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.0.3 Apolyton Civilization Forums > Miscellaneous > Archive > Off-Topic-Archive > Does God exist?
Show a Printable Version | Email This Page to Someone! | Receive updates to this thread | Report this to Apolyton news!

bottom of page
  
Author
Thread   
Pages (10): [ <<   5   6   7   8   9   10   ]
< Last Thread     Next Thread > Post New Thread     Post A Reply
Urban Ranger is offline Urban Ranger
Apolyton Duke of Off-Topic

Donate to the Red Cross
The City State of Noosphere, CPA special envoy
May 1999
time: 13:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 07:49
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#211 Report this post to a moderator
Full PM-box? Change here!

quote:
Originally posted by Kuciwalker
The search for the origin of the universe shouldn't exist - by definition nothing is outside of the universe, as the universe is the set of all that exists, therefore nothing outside of the universe exists. Ergo, an outside cause of the universe is nonexistant.


You have a very strange definition of what this universe is.

Urban Ranger is offline Urban Ranger
Apolyton Duke of Off-Topic

Donate to the Red Cross
The City State of Noosphere, CPA special envoy
May 1999
time: 13:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 07:51
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#212 Report this post to a moderator
Put an end to popups!

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
I've never seen New York. I believe it to be there, but only because of what others have told me. Does that mean that New York does not exist?


You can go visit New York and prove to yourself that it exists. The same thing cannot be said about your god.

Refuted.

Jon Miller is offline Jon Miller
Emperor

May 1999
time: 23:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 07:54
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#213 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy GURPS/ Alpha Centauri

no, New York is only one example

consider the moon, or the sun

Jon Miller

Japher is offline Japher
Prince
Ook! Ook! Ack! Ack! Ack!
Jun 2002
time: 05:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 07:57
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#214 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization: The Boardgame

I like to write. I don't consider myself a writter, but I just write sometimes. Here is the start of a story I write when I feel like writting... It's about a bunch of idiots searching for the origion of the universe. It's rather fun... to write that is, reading it kindof suks.

quote:

THE BEGINNING

In the beginning there was darkness, and then there was more darkness, until it was so dark that someone got really sick of it and said, “Man, it is really dark.”
And then someone else said, “Yup.”
Then the first voice said, “Can we do anything about it?”
And the other voice said, “Nope.”
So, the darkness went on for some time. It was a rather boring time, and not much happened at all. Then, in the darkness, the voice came, not the first voice the second one, “Hey!”
“What,” said the first voice.
“This.”
“What is this?”
“I don’t know, pull it?”
“O.k.”
And then there was light, a lot of light… and a weird smell.

THE MIDDLE

The universe was created in a day, this day, the day when the first voice pulled something in the dark and made stuff happen. That voice became known as the Creator. Not at first, mind you, it took some time before there was actually anyone to know of the Creator, or at least wonder where they came from. The big problem, however, came when these ones to know the Creator, let’s just call them “people”, started thanking and praising the Creator, the second voice got rather mad. Heck, why not? The second voice did find the thing to pull, but no, the Creator took all the credit.
So time passed. The “people” became rather “civil” and created a nice little “civilization” (fine, I’ll drop the quotes) of about four or five billion people that spread out across the planet called earth, which was relatively near where the thing that was pulled was located. They had cities, cars, planes, pretty much all the stuff we think of the modern day earth of having. Around this time, which was a long time after the thing was pulled and a little while after the people showed up, that some guy named Preston Herrington asked, “So what was that thing that was pulled?”
This was the beginning of the end.


Pretty much, man, you're wasting your time.

Urban Ranger is offline Urban Ranger
Apolyton Duke of Off-Topic

Donate to the Red Cross
The City State of Noosphere, CPA special envoy
May 1999
time: 13:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 07:58
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#215 Report this post to a moderator
Help yourself to an AD-FREE life

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
So? Theologians say the same.


Says the same of what? I have never seen, heard, or read about any theologian admitting that his brand of religion is limited. Especially Christian theologians.

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
Science cannot disprove the actions and the intervention of God on the world because of the inherent limitations of science.


The same old "god of the gaps" argument.

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
For the whole reason we debated earlier in the thread as to the necessity of a First Mover. This is why your first statement does not hold, that the same conundrum applying to the universe also applies to God.


If you could show conclusively that this universe needs a first mover, and that your god does not, you are better than any of the theologians ever lived. Make that you are better than all of them combined.

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 09:34
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#216 Report this post to a moderator
Increase the size of your Attachments

quote:
Originally posted by loinburger
I'll cite you on two counts of bullshit -- one for giving a faulty definition, and another for claiming that said definition is absolute.

First, when "universe" is used in a logical context, then entities can and do exist outside of the universe. The universe merely delimits the set of entities within the universe of discourse.


First pwnage:

quote:
u·ni·verse Audio pronunciation of "universe" ( P ) Pronunciation Key (yn-vûrs)
n.

1. All matter and energy, including the earth, the galaxies, and the contents of intergalactic space, regarded as a whole.
2.
1. The earth together with all its inhabitants and created things.
2. The human race.
3. The sphere or realm in which something exists or takes place.
4. Logic. See universe of discourse.

5. Statistics. See population.


Clicking "universe of discourse" gives:

quote:
universe of discourse
n. Logic

A class containing all the entities referred to in a discourse or an argument. Also called universe.


Clearly God is part of that universe.

quote:
Second, the meanings of words can and do change over time. Or do you wish to argue that computer bugs are organisms? You cannot simply cry "fallacy" and dismiss the scientific definition of "universe" in favor of Kuciwalker's ad hoc definition of "universe."


Philosophical meanings of terms do not. And since there is no explicit scientific definition of universe... your point doesn't mean anything at all.

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 09:35
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#217 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Call to Power 2

quote:
Originally posted by loinburger
Once the shrinking universe reaches a given mass/energy density then it collapses to a singularity and it doesn't really make sense to think of it as anything else at that point, because the laws that govern our universe don't apply in any meaningful sense (as far as we know) to the singularity. I suppose that we could still think of the singularity as "the universe," but even so we'd still be dealing with two entirely different entities -- the "normal universe," and the "singularity universe" -- when we make any statements concerning either. F'rinstance, we could no longer say "the universe is causal," because for all we know the rules governing a singularity are acausal. That's why it doesn't make sense to have both an eternal and expanding universe -- we'd be making the term "universe" pretty meaningless if we equated a singularity to what we're living in.


Continuous contraction doesn't have to be to a single point.

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 09:36
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#218 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization III: Complete

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi


Not so. Just because he can do something doesn't necessarily mean that he will do something.

If you are willing to concede to me that God can be responsible for these things, then that's all I'm asking.


It's obviously possible. It's also possible that God created the rest of the universe five seconds ago.

quote:
What source will you accept? Remember scientists cannot prove such a causal relationship because it is beyond the scope of science.


No it isn't... it's clearly empirical fact, whether or not he has intervened...

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 09:37
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#219 Report this post to a moderator
Enter the AD-FREE zone

quote:
Originally posted by Urban Ranger
You have a very strange definition of what this universe is.


You have a very poor memory.

I've been arguing this same point in every single thread about this topic.

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 09:38
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#220 Report this post to a moderator
Put an end to popups!

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
Like I said earlier, I believe there is some truth in the Hindu accounts of Vishnu, but that the Christians have had more revealed to them of the character of God.


The two are CONTRADICTORY!

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 09:50
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#221 Report this post to a moderator
Suffering from ads?

quote:

I have never seen, heard, or read about any theologian admitting that his brand of religion is limited. Especially Christian theologians.


That there are areas that they do not understand?

All theologians say that they cannot wholly conceive the mind of God, ergo, they know their religion to be limited in understanding God.

If they say otherwise, then we know this to be a fallacy, that if God is omniscient, then they would be unable to wholly conceive the mind of God, even if they claimed to have done so.

quote:

The same old "god of the gaps" argument.


Am I limiting God's involvement in the world to the time before Planck time? No. I'm saying that it is possible for God to intervene throughout history, rather than confining him to a gap.

quote:

If you could show conclusively that this universe needs a first mover, and that your god does not, you are better than any of the theologians ever lived. Make that you are better than all of them combined.


That's the real merit behind Anselm, in saying that if there were a power higher than God, or if what we called God had a mover before him, then we would call that being God.

If you say we have a finite universe, then it does not make sense that there can be an infinite regress of causality. There must be something that starts the whole process off.

Therefore, there must be a First Mover, of whatever sort, that by definition becomes God.

Now, if YHWH were not this first mover, in having a cause, then this First Mover would be God, and not YHWH. I cannot go from the principle of a First Mover to YHWH without additional presuppositions.

So from the combination of both principles, it seems obvious that there must be a First Mover, and regardless of that First Mover, we would call that First mover God.

Last edited by Ben Kenobi on 22-09-2004 at 09:56

Giancarlo is offline Giancarlo
King
Los Angeles
Apr 2000
time: 02:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 09:53 Visit Giancarlo's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#222 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Galactic Civilizations

I'd like for somebody to actually prove god, instead of speculating about it.

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:01
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#223 Report this post to a moderator
Avatar Enlargement: We've got the solution

quote:

It's obviously possible.


Thank you Skywalker. That's an important concession. You say that it is possible for God to intervene in the world, but it is an open question as to whether or not he has.

quote:

No it isn't... it's clearly empirical fact, whether or not he has intervened...


How would you ascertain the causal relationship empirically? It's not like a chemical reaction where you can isolate the reagents.

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:03
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#224 Report this post to a moderator
Lose 30 kilos (of popups)

quote:

The two are CONTRADICTORY!


How so?

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:05
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#225 Report this post to a moderator
Enter the AD-FREE zone

quote:

You can go visit New York and prove to yourself that it exists. The same thing cannot be said about your god.


Is that so?

"Blessed be the pure in heart, for they shall see God."

Giancarlo is offline Giancarlo
King
Los Angeles
Apr 2000
time: 02:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:07 Visit Giancarlo's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#226 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi


Is that so?

"Blessed be the pure in heart, for they shall see God."


Oh so my heart is unpure? What B.S...

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:08
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#227 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization III: Complete

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
How so?


Read the Bible. Read the Ramayana. See if you notice the subtle inconsistancies between the two...

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:09
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#228 Report this post to a moderator
Browse Apolyton AD-FREE

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
Thank you Skywalker. That's an important concession. You say that it is possible for God to intervene in the world, but it is an open question as to whether or not he has.


I've never disputed that?

quote:
How would you ascertain the causal relationship empirically? It's not like a chemical reaction where you can isolate the reagents.


That practical considerations would make experiment difficult doesn't change the fact that it is an empirical problem.

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:10
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#229 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton or Terrorists Win

quote:

There is no way you can talk to god (you are trying so hard to believe in something, and make something talk to yourself... you are hearing voices in your head).


Who says I hear voices in my head? He finds other ways to get my attention.

As for me talking to him, anyone can do so, there's no talent involved. That's what prayer is about. You stop, and talk to him.

quote:

The notion of god is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard of.... I can't believe people choose to believe in god(s), there are so many better things in life then a human imagined being.


True, if he were imaginary and our own construct it would seem pretty silly. But if he's God, then it's not.

Giancarlo is offline Giancarlo
King
Los Angeles
Apr 2000
time: 02:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:12 Visit Giancarlo's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#230 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Alpha Centauri

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi


Who says I hear voices in my head? He finds other ways to get my attention.

As for me talking to him, anyone can do so, there's no talent involved. That's what prayer is about. You stop, and talk to him.


You just scream about god to get attention. That's what I think. Prayer is just a cry for attention. You are not praying for anything. There isn't anything there... just your own desperation in wanting something to be there.

quote:
True, if he were imaginary and our own construct it would seem pretty silly. But if he's God, then it's not.


Oh please.. don't speak semantics with me...

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:12
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#231 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization: The Boardgame

quote:

Oh so my heart is unpure? What B.S...


UR says it's impossible for people to see God, unlike New York.

It has nothing to do with you Gian.

And I certainly have not seen him.

problem_child is offline problem_child
Warlord
State of the Animal
Mar 2000
time: 05:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:13
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#232 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton or Terrorists Win

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi

"Blessed be the pure in heart, for they shall see God."


Faith is just no substitute for truth. A good measure of the true value of faith can be discerned by a visit to any mental asylum.

I don't need to know sun exists in my heart to know it's there. I can't begin to fit the breadth and scope of the universe into my little brain. In my heart I can fit all kinds of little self-involved things.

Hearts are good, they pump blood, fill our chests, but they're only hearts.

As for purity... Life, by nature- is not about purity.

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:13
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#233 Report this post to a moderator
Suffering from ads?

quote:

Read the Bible. Read the Ramayana. See if you notice the subtle inconsistancies between the two...


You tell me.

Why should I do your work for you?

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:19
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#234 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization: The Boardgame

quote:

You just scream about god to get attention.


I have to scream in order for God to hear me?

quote:

That's what I think. Prayer is just a cry for attention.


You're right. After all that's what adoration, thanksgivings and contrition are all about.

quote:

You are not praying for anything. There isn't anything there... just your own desperation in wanting something to be there.


Desparation? No, it's like a walk. I'm walking, and he walks with me, and we talk about how things are going. Sure sometimes it's rough, but othertimes are much more joyful.

quote:

Oh please.. don't speak semantics with me...


Why would we dream up a God that hates sin when we revel in it?

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:20
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#235 Report this post to a moderator
Get a bigger avatar today!

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
You tell me.

Why should I do your work for you?


Perhaps... the part about polytheism?

Giancarlo is offline Giancarlo
King
Los Angeles
Apr 2000
time: 02:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:20 Visit Giancarlo's homepage!
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#236 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton buy from Amazon

quote:
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi


I have to scream in order for God to hear me?



You're right. After all that's what adoration, thanksgivings and contrition are all about.



Desparation? No, it's like a walk. I'm walking, and he walks with me, and we talk about how things are going. Sure sometimes it's rough, but othertimes are much more joyful.



Why would we dream up a God that hates sin when we revel in it?


Prove god.

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:21
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#237 Report this post to a moderator
Tired of ads?

quote:
Originally posted by loinburger
Second, the meanings of words can and do change over time. Or do you wish to argue that computer bugs are organisms? You cannot simply cry "fallacy" and dismiss the scientific definition of "universe" in favor of Kuciwalker's ad hoc definition of "universe."


The fallacy, btw, was at your appeal to authority.

Jon Miller is offline Jon Miller
Emperor

May 1999
time: 23:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:21
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#238 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization: The Boardgame

quote:
Originally posted by Kuciwalker


Perhaps... the part about polytheism?


did you not read BKs earlier post?

Jon Miller

Ben Kenobi is offline Ben Kenobi
Emperor
McGregornobi!
Oct 2002
time: 21:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:22
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#239 Report this post to a moderator
Support Apolyton, buy Civilization III: Complete

quote:

Faith is just no substitute for truth. A good measure of the true value of faith can be discerned by a visit to any mental asylum.


So all the believers are in asylums?

I'd try going to church if I were you. Might even out your perspective.

quote:

I don't need to know sun exists in my heart to know it's there. I can't begin to fit the breadth and scope of the universe into my little brain. In my heart I can fit all kinds of little self-involved things.


If you lived in a cave all your life, and never saw the sun, would you know that it exists?

quote:

As for purity... Life, by nature- is not about purity.


Very true. Which is why we are given a new life, apart from our natural one, one that does not wither or decay.

Kuciwalker is offline Kuciwalker
Emperor
of Schmooism
Feb 2001
time: 00:23
  Old Post 22-09-2004 10:23
Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
#240 Report this post to a moderator
Put an end to popups!

quote:
Originally posted by Jon Miller
did you not read BKs earlier post?

Jon Miller


I don't see how it accounts for blatant inconsistancies.

 
Pages (10): [ <<   5   6   7   8   9   10   ]
< Last Thread     Next Thread > Post New Thread     Post A Reply
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:23.
Apolyton Time is 00:23.
    top of page
Rate This Thread:
archivepost
Forum Jump:
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
 




Contact Us - Apolyton Civilization Site - Support Us!

Building a better Apolyton through better information. Click here and take our poll!
Non-US visitors, click here!

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.0.3
Copyright ©2000, 2001, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.

Page generated in 0.0775 seconds (92.02% PHP - 7.98% MySQL) with 31 queries
Page Loading Time:

Support Apolyton: Amazon USA | Amazon UK | Amazon DE | Amazon FR |
Support Apolyton and get FREE PLUS, Buy from Chips&Bits: Galactic Civilizations | Galactic Civilizations: Deluxe Edition | Call to Power 2 | Civilization: The Boardgame | GURPS/ Alpha Centauri | Alpha Centauri | Civilization IV | Civilization III: Complete |


Front Page | Civilization IV | Civilization III | Civilization II | Call to Power II | Alpha Centauri | Master of Orion III
Rise of Nations | Galactic Civilizations | Galactic Civilizations II | Misc
Alt.Civs | Civ I | C:CtP I | About | News | Directory | Apolyton Store | Forums | Chat | Columns | Interviews | Newsletter
Scenario League | CSC | Clash of Civs | Spanish Site | CtP Maps | Cradle of Civ | WesW's Ctp1/2 Site | Civ3 Haven

apolyton.net | apolyton.com | civilization2.net | civilization3.net | civilization4.net | civilizationiv.info | calltopower.net | galciv.net | galciv2.net | moo3.net