 |
|  |
 |
|
Tamerlin
|
 |
Toulouse (South-western France)
Apr 2002 time: 06:25
|
|
Stade Toulousain 26 - Sporting Union Agenais 6
Interesting first half followed by one of the poorest halves I have been given the opportunity to watch at. Fistfights, poor play, a mockery of Rugby in front of a crowd of 18,000 (a stadium "plein comme un oeuf" as we say, "as full as an egg"). The second half was so dull that after 30' of play we could believe the half had just started 2' ago, impossible to remember anything about it to the exception of a tough (but regular) tackle of Ntamack (Stade Toulousain) on an offended Gelez (France and Agen flyhalf), he was "vexé comme un pou" ("offended like a louse") as we say in France. 
A great surprise at Montferrand, the Football Club de Grenoble has won against the Association Sportive Montferrandaise 17-14, qualifying itself for the Play-Off (second phase leading to the semi-finals) and "qualifying" the Montferrandais for the Play-Down (leading to Pro D2, second division, for the last two clubs of the second phase to come). 
Bearcat, it is good to hear some Rugby news from the USA. It is interesting to note that the number of licensees in the USA is one of the highest in the world though it seems to be mainly a game played in the universities. I have heard that Rugby was starting to attract some audience and was currently gathering more and more followers. 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Bearcat
|
|
Oregonia
Dec 1999 time: 05:25
|
|
quote: Originally posted by finbar
Did you have to stand on a chair to reach his chin? If so, he was a lock.
|
Actually he punched me off the ground at a ruck. I was standing over the ruck and he was lying down on the ground (hence, why I said I thought it was a lock) and he reached up and punched me on the thigh. I hadn't kicked, hit, touched, or rucked him in any way to make him do it, so I was kind of offended and I started swinging away at him
quote: Originally posted by Tamerlin
Bearcat, it is good to hear some Rugby news from the USA. It is interesting to note that the number of licensees in the USA is one of the highest in the world though it seems to be mainly a game played in the universities. I have heard that Rugby was starting to attract some audience and was currently gathering more and more followers. |
Yes, most of the rugby played in the USA is played at the high school (my level) and college level. We do have a fair share of adult clubs though. My region has quite a few. One of our better rugby programs is the University of California at Berkely rugby team. They have been NCAA champions for something like 12 years running, and are coached by Jack Clark who was formerly a lock on the Eagles XV. I'm planning on continuing to play after I graduate high school, but I won't be going to Cal.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:25
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Bearcat
Actually he punched me off the ground at a ruck. I was standing over the ruck and he was lying down on the ground (hence, why I said I thought it was a lock) and he reached up and punched me on the thigh. I hadn't kicked, hit, touched, or rucked him in any way to make him do it, so I was kind of offended and I started swinging away at him |
If you'd asked him if his name was J**** and he'd grunted in the affirmative, I wouldn't have been in the least surprised.
quote: Yes, most of the rugby played in the USA is played at the high school (my level) and college level. We do have a fair share of adult clubs though. My region has quite a few. One of our better rugby programs is the University of California at Berkely rugby team. They have been NCAA champions for something like 12 years running, and are coached by Jack Clark who was formerly a lock on the Eagles XV. I'm planning on continuing to play after I graduate high school, but I won't be going to Cal. |
Bear in mind, Bearcat, if you'll pardon the ripping off of part of your name, that we, of this thread, will support you and your American colleagues in the development of the game in your country. Until you get too good, when we will do our best to undermine you. For example, look at all us SH posters and our attitude to England.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Bearcat
|
|
Oregonia
Dec 1999 time: 05:25
|
|
quote: Originally posted by finbar
If you'd asked him if his name was J**** and he'd grunted in the affirmative, I wouldn't have been in the least surprised. |
No, he wasn't bald. Couldn't of been Martin Johnson.
quote: Bear in mind, Bearcat, if you'll pardon the ripping off of part of your name, that we, of this thread, will support you and your American colleagues in the development of the game in your country. Until you get too good, when we will do our best to undermine you. For example, look at all us SH posters and our attitude to England. |
That probably won't be for another 10 years or so, when Americans finally realize rugby's innate superiority to football and b*sketball. In any case, I'm sure I'll remember what you said if and when the Eagles ever beat the Wallabies 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:25
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
It resulted in a situation where one prop and two hookers were on the field. One of those Hookers (Azam) can and has played prop but was less than forthcoming on the fact shall we say. |
A-ha. One prop and two hookers. That situation arose in S12 either last season or the season before. The scrum was contested. It does depend on the experience - and courage - of the spare hooker. A certain Les Bleus supporter, of course, would explain that differentiating between contested and uncontested scrums in the SH scrum is the ultimate definition of splitting straws.
quote: For all the criticism we get from other supporters we do have a history of ?taking it on the chin?. |
Not often enough. Oh! You were writing metaphorically ... Sorry! As you were.
quote: Smacks of ?Shamateurism? still does it not? |
Smacks of nonsense to me. Unless, eons ago, a team could lose a match because of an uncontested scrum. I can't believe it, though.
quote: Difficult to know what to say here Bearcat! |
I had no problem finding something to say in reply.
quote: You know what Finbar ? I like this guy. Good attitude. |
Learning too fast for my liking! 
quote: I think Finbar has only ever hinted at that in regards to the ABs last year. I recall him being quite critical of the Wallabies after the Ireland game? |
Hinted? An entire second-string scrum packs down? And, despite your claim - statistically - to have pushed them off the park, the onfield evidence was to the contrary. Be that as it may, I did pay out on the Wallabies after the Ireland game. They deserved it. I've since seen a mini-doco on the NH tour. S. Larkham explained away the Irish debacle on the basis that the defence coach had been drilling new moves into the team and the team got confused. Spare me, please! 
quote: Ah it was similar for me too. Minus the running part. |
I wish you hadn't written that. I now shan't sleep tonight for fear of closing my eyes and seeing Havak hauling himself around the paddock! 
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Tamerlin
|
 |
Toulouse (South-western France)
Apr 2002 time: 06:25
|
|
quote: Originally posted by finbar
A certain Les Bleus supporter, of course, would explain that differentiating between contested and uncontested scrums in the SH scrum is the ultimate definition of splitting straws. |
Hey! This is my job to hit you with the stick you have handled me. 

quote: Smacks of nonsense to me. Unless, eons ago, a team could lose a match because of an uncontested scrum. I can't believe it, though. |
In this case shame should kill! I would have no qualms at declaring the game lost for Gloucester as what they have done is like cheating. 
I am really angry because the grotesque behaviour of these fools are killing the game of Rugby. In the French Championship, two clubs have already used this trick to avoid a loss this year (and one is Montferrand which we can consider as my Gloucester though the place of most disliked club in France is now contested by Agen and the pitiful spirit of its supporters). There are more and more reports about uncontested scrums in the various championships and it is really a shame. In the Six Nations Tournament the SH referees (and Mr Honiss ahead of the others) are clearly hindering, if not preventing, the scrum work. In the S12 and the Tri-Nations the scrums are almost uncontested since a few years now and the leaders of the NH unions are defending the scrum with the vigor and the speed of a snail. 
I don't want our game to become a crossover between Rugby and L*****. 
quote: Learning too fast for my liking!  |
Come on Bearcat, this means you are on the good path... 
quote: Hinted? An entire second-string scrum packs down? And, despite your claim - statistically - to have pushed them off the park, the onfield evidence was to the contrary. |
See Bearcat, you have ten years to prepare yourself though you have an advantage over Havak, and only a half one over Caligastia, as you are not English... 
quote: I wish you hadn't written that. I now shan't sleep tonight for fear of closing my eyes and seeing Havak hauling himself around the paddock! |
Fear? I would have thought you would rather burst out laughing... 
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Havak
|
 |
Swing Low, Sweet Chariots.
Aug 1999 time: 05:25
|
|
quote: No, J****'s not bald. Just lantern-jawed and on the dim side. |
The guy reportedly has a keen analytical mind.
quote: It does depend on the experience - and courage - of the spare hooker |
But here is the thing – the initial hooker was the one with propping experience –surely the hooker who came on could have ‘hooked’ whilst the incumbent moved to prop? 
quote: differentiating between contested and uncontested scrums in the SH scrum is the ultimate definition of splitting straws. |

quote: Not often enough. Oh! You were writing metaphorically ... Sorry! As you were. |
You are really on form today. 
quote: Smacks of nonsense to me. Unless, eons ago, a team could lose a match because of an uncontested scrum. I can't believe it, though. |
Anything is possible in the murky past of British rugger. But the regs should have been read more carefully recently that is for sure. 
quote: I had no problem finding something to say in reply. |
But something with a grain of truth would have been nice. 
quote: Learning too fast for my liking! |
Yes, definitely showing promise. 
quote: An entire second-string scrum packs down? And, despite your claim - statistically - to have pushed them off the park, the onfield evidence was to the contrary. |
Okay, so it was a STRONG hint then. 
Onfield ‘evidence’ is a tricky thing – we had nearly two thirds of the ball and that’s something tangible in black and white. You might then rightfully criticise us for not utilising it much. 
quote: S. Larkham explained away the Irish debacle on the basis that the defence coach had been drilling new moves into the team and the team got confused. Spare me, please! |
A classic example of a team not taking it on the chin perhaps? 
quote: I now shan't sleep tonight for fear of closing my eyes and seeing Havak hauling himself around the paddock! |
It’s a justifiably scary image. 
quote: In this case shame should kill! I would have no qualms at declaring the game lost for Gloucester as what they have done is like cheating. |
I could argue they hate us so much, and are so jealous of our recent success that they would feel no shame had they fielded 30 men to beat us. 
Maybe the scrums do need looking at again. I’m not sure I should comment on Mr Honiss again though? I thought some of our scrums against the SH sides in November were fiercely contested in actual fact. I think they realised it was not an aspect of the game to ignore against us.
quote: I don't want our game to become a crossover between Rugby and L*****. |
And there of course is the fear we face with these scrum machinations by coaches.
quote: See Bearcat, you have ten years to prepare yourself though you have an advantage over Havak, and only a half one over Caligastia, as you are not English... |
Until such time as your forwards become as good as ours or France’s at which time Finbar will try to subvert their superiority with what I would call ‘rose-tinted recall’ as above.
On the other hand he will no doubt accuse me of exactly the same, at which point I have to reply – England won!

There – saved loads of time. 
quote: Fear? I would have thought you would rather burst out laughing... |
Only those with a life saving turn of pace ever dared to laugh. Those without that, or with poor side steps, tended to see the serious side of things. And from a radically new perspective. 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:25
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
The guy reportedly has a keen analytical mind. |
Your use of the word "reportedly" is noted.
quote: But here is the thing ? the initial hooker was the one with propping experience ?surely the hooker who came on could have ?hooked? whilst the incumbent moved to prop? |
Well, indeed. Sounds like a put-up job, which is a pity.
quote: You are really on form today. |
A bit liverish. One of my heirloom tomato seedlings keeled over and died. Ungrateful bastard of a thing! 
quote: But something with a grain of truth would have been nice. |
Precedents are dangerous things to set.
quote: Onfield ?evidence? is a tricky thing ? we had nearly two thirds of the ball and that?s something tangible in black and white. You might then rightfully criticise us for not utilising it much. |
Yes, indeed, so I win the argument either way. 
quote: Maybe the scrums do need looking at again. I?m not sure I should comment on Mr Honiss again though? I thought some of our scrums against the SH sides in November were fiercely contested in actual fact. I think they realised it was not an aspect of the game to ignore against us. |
I don't know about north of the equator, but this season's S12 is seeing the refs - as well as very strictly policing the tackler rolling away and entering "through the gate" behind the last feet - also cracking down on the front row activities. They're getting one warning about pushing before the ball is in before they're penalised. They're getting one warning about going in straight and level - rather than angled and upwards - before they're penalised. I'm sure it's all coming from the IRB in preparation for the WRC. And the refs, obviously, are performing to the letter of the IRB law because they want brownie points towards getting a reffing gig in the WRC.
quote: Only those with a life saving turn of pace ever dared to laugh. Those without that, or with poor side steps, tended to see the serious side of things. And from a radically new perspective. |
SCENE: A muddy paddock somewhere deep in rural Leicester.
CAST: HAVAK, HIS COACH
COACH: "Hey Havak! Run! The play's fifty yards away!"
HAVAK: "If I wait here long enough it'll come back this way!"


|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:25. Apolyton Time is 00:25. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|