 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Havak
|
 |
Swing Low, Sweet Chariots.
Aug 1999 time: 05:31
|
|
quote: Note too that the problem was the French were already waiting for reinforcement in the tight five at this time, so the ref shouldn't have let the Irish play at this time. |
An injury replacement or a tactical one? The latter is entirely at the referee’s discretion whereas he can’t allow a scrum without the former taking place.
quote: On performance, you are joint worst with us |
Oh I beg to differ. As my French colleagues have pointed out unless Australia improve a thousand fold the ABs will arrive in the final without having been tested at all.
We are playing badly – but we know we can play better. Can a Wallaby side likely to be bereft of Smith and Giteau lift their game at all? I think you are playing about as well as you can right now – and that’s the difference for me. 
quote: Mmmmmm. That grenouille back row is a delight to watch in action. |
It’s working in a way that ours is markedly failing to that’s for sure. Wilko must be really looking forward to having Betsen living in his lap. Looks like we will have to task Moody to take Betsen out early doors – preferably with a bulldozer. 
quote: and hopefully further irritating the crap out of you. |
I’m certainly not a big fan of Bath – as may have been hinted at over the years. But I prefer to concentrate on our very pleasant unexpected victory over the defending champions. 
If you think Eddie is having hissy fits try to dig out the post match interview Clive had with what I believe was a French reporter – it’s priceless. 
I wonder, if Hill finally gets fit, if we might see a very different back row next weekend. Dally simply isn’t doing it, and Backy (very sadly) may be showing his age at last – I wonder if Moody-Hill-Worseley if worth a punt (not that Joe has impressed hugely).
But I tell you what would help us most –if the half backs channels were left largely to 9 and 10. I’ve complained about it before but we are still having everyone trying to play there – even the tight head was popping up in the stand off channel yesterday – it sort of stops us imposing any structure on our game!
quote: And, most telling of all, I think, England's apparent inability to deal with this |
That is very true to a certain extent. Perhaps worth saying that it’s a sign of a very good side that they can be wrong footed so thoroughly and still get the results?? 
I’m afraid LdiCesare was right about the ABs for me – they are being very efficient but really no one has asked them huge questions yet – Wales came closest perhaps?
quote: Do you think J**** was carrying an injury? He never seemed to get out of first gear and had so little impact. |
Are you kidding? He made a huge hit on the replacement scrummy late on that killed a Welsh move on the England line. He didn’t have a towering game – but then Wales were spinning fast wide ball and that doesn’t normally indicate you’ll see much of Jonno chasing them.
Luger was the one who had a really poor game – you may have seen the last of him. Which brings me to my main point – AUSTIN FLEW OUT YESTERDAY.

quote: One for each Welsh try Havak? |
Plus one for Lugers ground losing ‘clearance kick’ and a double tap for the stupid move with Kay on the wing (directly causing Stephen Jones opening try). And there’s also a new rut in my carpet! 
quote: If we are to believe a neutral and very recommendable witness who went in Australia to support the Lions a few years ago it seems that you are the only Australian supporter with the said ounce. |
My own experience was very much that knowledgeable rugby fans like Finbar are a small minority at Wallaby test matches. It is possible the hype around that particular series pulled in the wrong crowd. 
I would present this for the prosecution – the Wallabies are tucking away a very poor Scots side and late on the Scots try a desperate kick over the Aussies that Danielli chases. Sailor, against type it has to be said, collects the ball well and passes the ball back for a safe clearance as Danielli makes a desperation dive. Does the Aussie crowd applaud their player for a good piece of play do you think? No – they jeer and mock the Scots winger. It’s very distasteful (soccer like) and a sadly growing factor in watching rugby. The Aussies seem a few years ahead of some down the slide of crowds behaving in this way – I really dislike it. before Finbar points it out you would get exactly the same at Kingsholm yes – but that is an exception here still.
Oh and lets not forget guys that the semis have not been played yet. Until they are it’s still possible for Australia and England to make the final – however unlikely. After all we both have the best part of a week to learn how to play rugby again. No pressure there. 
And the English have a secret weapon – if anyone can make French discipline break down then it’s us. Remember 1991 lads? 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:31
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
We are playing badly – but we know we can play better. Can a Wallaby side likely to be bereft of Smith and Giteau lift their game at all? I think you are playing about as well as you can right now – and that’s the difference for me. |
Of course the Wallabies can play better. They can play much much better. The problem is, they're not. Typically, they'll lift against the ABs as they always do. Whether it's enough is another matter. We've won unconvincingly. As England has. If Ireland and Scotland had given us half a dozen stupid penalties in the second half within kicking distance as Wales did for you, our scorelines would have been inflated too. The fundamental difference between us remains that we're not ranked #1 in the world. 
Giteau's no chance, and Smith is now 70-30. The problem with Smith is that we desperately need another lineout option, so one of either Smith or Waugh will have to go. Unless there's an alternative that hasn't occurred to me. Oh that Owen Finegan were a couple of years younger. It's wonderful having two great scavengers, but it comes at a cost.
quote: Wilko must be really looking forward to having Betsen living in his lap. |
Fear not, Mike Catt will once more ride to the rescue and hold the boy's hand. BTW, does Mr Catt set his hair with Plaster of Paris?
quote: Looks like we will have to task Moody to take Betsen out early doors – preferably with a bulldozer. |
Methinks M'sieur Betsen might use young Moody for kindling to start the fire to brew his post-match macchiato.
quote: I’m certainly not a big fan of Bath – as may have been hinted at over the years. |
You're not? Sorry, I must have missed your subtlety.
quote: But I prefer to concentrate on our very pleasant unexpected victory over the defending champions. |
I like the way one of the websites, I think it was the Zurich one, said Leicester had avoided the relegation zone (or similar). I'm actually thinking of cashing in my superannuation and funding Rotheram to lease the French pack and #s 9 and 10 for the rest of your season.
quote: If you think Eddie is having hissy fits try to dig out the post match interview Clive had with what I believe was a French reporter – it’s priceless. |
Well, who would want the pressure they're under? Obviously Clive knows that if he bombs out this weekend, nothing the media has put Eddie through here will register against what the English media will do to him.
quote: I wonder, if Hill finally gets fit, if we might see a very different back row next weekend. Dally simply isn’t doing it, and Backy (very sadly) may be showing his age at last – I wonder if Moody-Hill-Worseley if worth a punt (not that Joe has impressed hugely). |
I'm sure Clive is praying for Hill's return. Neil Back just isn't being allowed to play his usual game. He, like a lot of them, has often been on the back foot. But I think he's showing his age, too. I noticed Dalaglio swatting away one of his teammates who was trying to ease him out of that trouble that arose after either a scrum or a ruck. There was a story here that Wilkinson had a tizz with teammates in a Brisbane restaurant last week. I have no idea how true it is. At least I have the name of the restaurant. I might ring them and find out.
Anyway, I've seen nothing from Worsley to indicate that he's the answer. I think you have to pray that the opposition stops jumping you from the kickoff. Or pray Clive or J**** has come up with some better means of reacting to the oppo taking the initiative. Near panic, which seems to be the current play, has its limitations.
quote: But I tell you what would help us most –if the half backs channels were left largely to 9 and 10. I’ve complained about it before but we are still having everyone trying to play there – even the tight head was popping up in the stand off channel yesterday – it sort of stops us imposing any structure on our game! |
That's right. What's more, the Welsh were smashing anyone around there or closer in.
One of the commentators said that Charvis doesn't have a domestic contract next (or this?) season. What's the story there?
quote: That is very true to a certain extent. Perhaps worth saying that it’s a sign of a very good side that they can be wrong footed so thoroughly and still get the results?? |
Ditto the Wallabies, presumably. 
quote: I’m afraid LdiCesare was right about the ABs for me – they are being very efficient but really no one has asked them huge questions yet – Wales came closest perhaps? |
Wales did. And they, eventually, handled them better than England did.
quote: Are you kidding? He made a huge hit on the replacement scrummy late on that killed a Welsh move on the England line. |
Yes, and? This is J****, inspiring heart and soul of the team. I remember him vividly when they were down a couple of players earlier in the year. I think he took it up two or three times last night, if that. I suspect there was something wrong.
quote: He didn’t have a towering game – but then Wales were spinning fast wide ball and that doesn’t normally indicate you’ll see much of Jonno chasing them. |
See above.
quote: Luger was the one who had a really poor game – you may have seen the last of him. |
I'm sure I've seen greater fear on a rugby field, but I can't remember when. (Yes, I can. Mr Catt -v- Mr Lomu ) Oh, and I won't be so unkind as to suggest that Luger's try-scoring chickens come home to roost. 
quote: Which brings me to my main point – AUSTIN FLEW OUT YESTERDAY. |
Yes, I know. Thankfully he was yabbering as much as ever, the check-in counter misheard, and he's on his way to Austria.
quote: and a double tap for the stupid move with Kay on the wing (directly causing Stephen Jones opening try). |
Who was it who kicked? It was madness.
quote: My own experience was very much that knowledgeable rugby fans like Finbar are a small minority at Wallaby test matches. |
I'm in a very small minority in this country. It's called "one".
quote: Oh and lets not forget guys that the semis have not been played yet. Until they are it’s still possible for Australia and England to make the final – however unlikely. After all we both have the best part of a week to learn how to play rugby again. No pressure there. |
Not on us. The IRB has us ranked fourth, remember? 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Havak
|
 |
Swing Low, Sweet Chariots.
Aug 1999 time: 05:31
|
|
quote: Of course the Wallabies can play better. They can play much much better. The problem is, they're not. |
I’m really not sure they can. They have relied so long on the Gregan-Larkham axis that now both are off form together they seem all at sea. Giteau seemed to add some real creativity in the short time he featured.
If he drops Smith who comes into the back row?
quote: Fear not, Mike Catt will once more ride to the rescue and hold the boy's hand. BTW, does Mr Catt set his hair with Plaster of Paris? |
Probably. Another Bath Poser don’t you know. 
quote: Methinks M'sieur Betsen might use young Moody for kindling to start the fire to brew his post-match macchiato. |
Maybe so, maybe so. Don’t be hugely surprised if the Englishman upsets those odds (by not appearing if Hill is fit). 
Oh and save your money – Rotherham are a dead duck. 
quote: Obviously Clive knows that if he bombs out this weekend, nothing the media has put Eddie through here will register against what the English media will do to him. |
Believe it. They will force him to resign without a doubt.
quote: There was a story here that Wilkinson had a tizz with teammates in a Brisbane restaurant last week. I have no idea how true it is |
It sounds like wishful thinking. The squad uses a siege mentality to it’s advantage most of the time – they are a very close knit unit. I find it hard to give any credence to this – can you fish around for more info?
quote: Near panic, which seems to be the current play, has its limitations. |
Damn right. I hope they look at the numbers on their shirt and ask someone what the position is, that they build patiently and stop trying to force things, and that they get right up their in French faces and say “bring it on” in the best tradition of sporting forwards. I was going to use the old “Sister and Mother” line there but thought better of it 
Charvis fell out with the franchise his club ended up in and has indeed settled for a retirement move to the French lower divisions. Amazing what two good games can do for a career eh? 
quote: Ditto the Wallabies, presumably. |
I am generous enough to extend that with some qualification yes. The qualification being I think they are more resilient than good. So now watch them beat the ABs and prove me an 

quote: Wales did. And they, eventually, handled them better than England did. |
Oh much better. They were so impressive in so doing I thought we should just hand them the trophy now. 
They used their strengths – and they got a healthy dose of luck towards the end too. Take away the try that gave them daylight (as some refs certainly would have) and how impressive would those last few minutes have been?
Wales fronted up superbly against both of us – and lets give them full credit for that first and foremost.
If there is something wrong with Jonno physically the camp is being ultra tight lipped about it. And I think you are remembering Lomu versus Underwood jnr, something that still gives me nightmares!
Tindall kicked across field to Kay for the Welsh opening score. The rumour here is Austin was cavity searched by customs upon arrival (anonymous tip off received from somewhere in NSW apparently).
And I’m not living in the past – I’m living entirely for next weekend at the moment. 
Oh and the new rankings are 1) NZ 2) England 3) France 4) Australia 5) Boks. Both NZ and England have played and beaten the Boks but apart form that the ABs are back on top for various minnow whackings. 
Mais naturellement mon ami. 
quote: This is obvious to anyone who can see the replays of the said actions (and I have seen them again just before the beginnning of this WC) |
Well you memory of the event is therefore fresher. I watched it live and vaguely remember the garryowen tactic (one of Blanco’s few vulnerabilities) and the injury to Blanco – but I don’t recall any hint of it being malicious (and it would seem not just referee but touch official must have agreed with me?). In any case if it was deliberate that is shocking and I apologise on behalf of right thinking fans throughout the country.
None of that though excuses the stupidity of the players in the pack who got carded. When Ali Williams used Lewsey as a climbing frame in June the English forwards didn’t start punching the nearest black shirt. When Toutai Kefu got a nasty late challenge from behind by Mr Kempson in the tri-nations the Aussies were angry but kept their discipline. The tackle on Blanco is possibly a reason for what they did – but it’s no excuse at all.
quote: It is as if Betsen, Magne and Harinordoquy were given the order to catch Johnny Wilkinson in order to wound and incapacitate him. This is not acceptable whatever the team. |
True. Shall we keep an eye on those gentlemen then as all three will at various times be looking to hit him as hard as they possible can. The slightest mis-timing could be very serious indeed for Jonny.
quote: Hospital mocking charity. |
In a way – although the disciplinary record of Carling’s England wasn’t too bad for the era. 
quote: Don't count on it though and remember there are also some ways to irritate some English players not sure of their Rugby. |
Can I give you some advice? Spin it wide quickly and you may have wingers running one at one at English locks and props drifting stupidly in a wingers position. 
quote: You should fill and send the documents right now, I have heard that the process is rather long. |
I’ll keep my pen ready for Sunday. 
Bring me my bow of burning gold!
Bring me my arrows of desire!
Bring me my spear! O clouds, unfold!
Bring me my chariot of fire!
I will not cease from mental fight,
Nor shall my sword sleep in my hand,
Till we have built Jerusalem
In England's green and pleasant land.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:31
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
I’m really not sure they can. They have relied so long on the Gregan-Larkham axis that now both are off form together they seem all at sea. Giteau seemed to add some real creativity in the short time he featured. |
He did. Top class player in the making. Good enough now, in fact, to be playing in front of Larkham in his current form. But, of course, the injury kills that possibility! Not that it would've happened anyway. 
quote: If he drops Smith who comes into the back row? |
He won't. Well, he hasn't. But Cockbain would probably start in his place.
quote: Oh and save your money – Rotherham are a dead duck. |
You hope.
quote: It sounds like wishful thinking. The squad uses a siege mentality to it’s advantage most of the time – they are a very close knit unit. I find it hard to give any credence to this – can you fish around for more info? |
Apparently he arrived late, had an argument with some teammates, and left again immediately. I'll dig out the name of the restaurant and get their phone number. You can ring them. From work, of course.
quote: Wales fronted up superbly against both of us – and lets give them full credit for that first and foremost. |
I do. There are some very good young players in that side. Hope for the future, perhaps.
quote: And I think you are remembering Lomu versus Underwood jnr, something that still gives me nightmares! |
Was that who Lomu ran over the top of? I thought it was Catt.
quote: The rumour here is Austin was cavity searched by customs upon arrival (anonymous tip off received from somewhere in NSW apparently). |
They asked him to spread his cheeks, and, quite appropriately for him, he opened his mouth.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:31. Apolyton Time is 00:31. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|