 |
| |
|
|
Sava
|
 |
GO GO GO!
Mar 2001
time: 23:33
|
|
berz... as I pointed out... the "small difference" has to do with foreign policy and projection of power...
US imperialism has outdone anything the Nazis could have hoped for...
13 colonies... to the entire annihilation of the Native American culture as it existed... expanding to the present day "continental" US. Hawaii, Phillipines, Panama, other South Pacific islands... Cuba was in the cross-hairs, but the Spanish kept us in check, then the Soviets... Puerto Rico...
WWI, yeah, we came to the aid of allies and other free societies... 
WW2... came to the aid of free societies again... although we provoked Japan into attacking us...
Korea  , trying to exert influence in the region... trying to stop communism (btw if communism is so flawed, why did we need to fight to stop it? capitalists never explain this)
Vietnam US kills over 4 million in another vain attempt at projecting power...
then there's South and Latin America... propping up dictators, supporting violent revolutions against democratically elected leaders that didn't want to play ball...
then there's the mideast and the muslim world... we supported Momar (our buddy in Libya), messed around in Iran until it blew up in our faces... same with Iraq...
This imperialism in the muslim world reminds me so much of 19th Century Africa... the Christians and capitalists were going to spread "civilized" culture to Africa... the different powers used that mantra to justify raping, exploiting, and colonizing the continent... and look where Africa is now. The Muslim world is much different. They are going to resist Democracy and westernization to the death... this is another crusade, but we don't call it that.
IMO, that's not too different from Nazi Germany... Hitler wanted to spread his master race across the globe... America wants to spread it's culture and impose it's economic superiority over the world, damn the innocent casualties.
Clear enough for you? I don't give a **** what Rome, or the Soviets, or anybody else did... it doesn't make America's policies just... it doesn't make us morally superior just because the US isn't killing people in factory death houses.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Berzerker
|
 |
topeka, kansas,USA
May 1999
time: 23:33
|
|
UR, you've changed the issue from mass murder and mass starvation to "war criminal". Can you quote me accusing Stalin or Mao of being war criminals? I said their behavior ranks among the top 10 crimes of the 20th century.
quote:
Mao had never intended to be evil, but sometimes very nasty effects occurred as a consequences of his actions, such as the Cultural Revolution. |
Holy Sh!t... How many did he starve? How many did he send to "re-education" centers? How many did he slaughter? Yeah, "nasty effects" of the "cultural revolution". And Stalin was as bad or worse, between these two SOBs, 10's of millions lost their lives. Strange, there's a huge outcry directed at holocaust deniers but when it comes to these thugs...well...strange indeed. Btw, wasn't Mao the leader of the Chinese communists in the war against the Chinese nationalists (now Taiwanese)?
Sava, we'll let the audience decide. 
There is a "very small difference" between the Nazis and America.
America is worse than the Roman Empire.
And these gems were about America over the last ~60 years. 
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
|
CharlesBHoff
|
|
el paso texas
May 2002
time: 05:33
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by Spiffor
Stalin has kept war prisoners in terrible conditions and for an outrageous time after peace had been signed. German civilians suffered from brutalities as they were being conquered. And needless to say, Stalin's absurd decisions as megalomaniac paranoid murderer lead to the useless death of millions sviet soldiers.
As for Mao being a war criminal, I indeed fail to see in which war he was directly involved, except WW2 against the Japanese. I don't think Mao standed out as being particularly evil at that time. |
Mao isnot than war criminal like Stalin, Bush, Blair, and Hilter.
Unless you count China entering the war on North Korea side. First we have troop on the boarder with China an then we have one of our top general make threat about invadeing China an useing nuclear weapons on China. America use biowarfare on China and China have the proof of this to pove it in an Internation Court, other nations saw the evidence like Canada, France and USSR.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
CharlesBHoff
|
|
el paso texas
May 2002
time: 05:33
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by notyoueither
Oh, Good Lord. The door of the looney bin must be open. |
Not really. Germany was than anti-semtic nation since the middle age. The Nazie where not the only party which where anti-jewish, all the parties in Germany where basic anti-jewish to get the vote they needed to win electon.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
CharlesBHoff
|
|
el paso texas
May 2002
time: 05:33
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by Spiffor
I don't think my image is stored anywhere near my name in places I don't want, such as buses and supermarkets.
Besides, I'm 99% sure nobody stored my fingerpirnts, unless the French police goes against the law and secretly stores them.
If the French are ever to be IDed in such a way in American airports, I'll seriously reconsider any possible trip there. For me, such a breach in privacy is very serious. |
When I have to vist my father in pirson they took my fingerprint but only the pirson system have them.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
CharlesBHoff
|
|
el paso texas
May 2002
time: 05:33
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by DanS
Stop pulling things out of your ass. Fact is, nobody knows who did it. |
They do have than name of than america who worked in our biowarfare department who is than fundie Christian and that why he isnot behind bar right now.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Berzerker
|
|
topeka, kansas,USA
May 1999
time: 23:33
|
|
Btw Spiffor, I believe when geography and population is considered, the Emirs of Kuwait have let more Palestinian refugees settle in their country than any other in the region.
Those evil bastards! 
Sava - quote:
berz... as I pointed out... the "small difference" has to do with foreign policy and projection of power...
US imperialism has outdone anything the Nazis could have hoped for... |
Oh, now the "clarifications" are coming from the backtracker.
We weren't debating the past 240 years. This is what you said to trigger the debate:
quote:
he's right
the difference between Nazi Germany and America is very small... both are corporatist states... it's only that Hitler wanted to kill everyone else... the elite in America would rather have economic slavery. |
Obviously "corporatist America" refers only to that period when corporations existed and exhibited alleged control of the nation. Being generous, that would mean you're talking about the 1890's on...
Here was your first "clarification":
quote:
I specified that is the difference... |
Which does nothing more than refer back to your first assertion which makes no mention of imperialism, the 18th century, foreign policy, etc...
And here is your second "clarification" at the bottom of page 2:
quote:
yes, as a world superpower... the US is more destructive than even the Roman Empire was... stop living in denial |
That's funny, it really is. But the US did not become a superpower until WWII , so why are you now bringing up the 18th and 19th centuries?
I'm on page 4 now looking for more "clarifications"...
Ah, was this it?
quote:
and by no means did I say "Nazi Germay = USA". In fact, the two are quite different. I was simply pointing out that they are similar in some aspects, and that we should strive to not be like them. |
Sounds more like an ambiguous retraction than a clarification.
quote:
I'm CLARIFYING because you obviously misunderstood what I said |
Oh, it wasn't a retraction? Then what exactly did you clarify other than your ability to contradict yourself?
quote:
berz... as I pointed out... the "small difference" has to do with foreign policy and projection of power...
US imperialism has outdone anything the Nazis could have hoped for... |
Ah, page 5 and we have the clarification now. So the Nazis slaughtered millions of foreigners when projecting their power and would have slaughtered millions more before getting stomped by all their enemies. How many did "corporatist America" kill? And no, I don't mean in defense of people the Nazis and commies were trying to conquer. Well, there was the Spanish-American War but not many people were killed in that one and it isn't like the Spanish weren't butchers. Then there would be...hmm... Gee... I don't know... Tell us, Sava, what were all these crimes committed by corporatist America that constitute a "very small difference" with the Nazis?
quote:
13 colonies... to the entire annihilation of the Native American culture as it existed... expanding to the present day "continental" US. Hawaii, Phillipines, Panama, other South Pacific islands... Cuba was in the cross-hairs, but the Spanish kept us in check, then the Soviets... Puerto Rico... |
Now now, Sava, you're backtracking again. You're including history that doesn't fall under "corporatist America". And that "Spanish kept us in check" bit is *******
At no point in this thread did I refer to all of US history, just the past ~60 years, you know the time frame when we can compare the Nazis, commies and the USA as I stated way back on the first page, here:
quote:
Hell, the US has liberated dozens of countries in the last 60 years... Do you want to blame the corporations for that too? |
See? We were debating the behavior of the US over the last ~60 years, not 240 years. My comment about what the US has done over the last ~60 years is what started you on your crusade about evil America so don't pretend we've been debating the 18th and 19th centuries now. It took you to page 5 to start in on all of US history, quite a "clarification" there. 
quote:
now, by disagreeing with me, you are saying Nazi Germany or Rome was a bigger Empire that the US... and you are wrong.... as usual... |
Hmm... I don't know about that. Where are our vast holdings? Puerto Rico? Guam? Rome was limited by logistics, not by desire. And the Nazis...well... their 3rd Reich lasted ~13 years, hardly enough time to build an empire but what they did conquer was quite impressive nonetheless. The US had ~%99 of its territory by the time it became "corporatist" and I hope you aren't suggesting vast open spaces with extremely small population densities are in the same category as the heavily occupied lands the Nazis and Romans were intent on taking.
UR - quote:
Sorry, I don't argue with sound-bites. |
Or facts
quote:
Strange indeed, to draw even a parallel between these. |
You don't think the slaughter of 10's of millions by Stalin and Mao are not "parallel" to Hitler's holocaust? Maybe the Chinese and Russian victims of these criminals just don't get enough attention in the media...
quote:
The point of this being? |
I believe you doubted his involvement in any war.
Last edited by Berzerker on 05-01-2004 at 13:26
|
|
| |
|
|
|
CharlesBHoff
|
|
el paso texas
May 2002
time: 05:33
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by Spiffor
I don't touch many things the police can identify as being touched be me. |
Finding fingerprint mean nothing at as evindence all it found in a public place like than mall of supermarket. It found on the safe door then it evidence.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
CharlesBHoff
|
|
el paso texas
May 2002
time: 05:33
|
|
quote:
Originally posted by notyoueither
Spiffor is going to say that any liberal democracy is preferable to any potentate, and many people would agree. |
Hilter was voted into power by the Germany people. The Germany mitilary never liked Hilter much than they have to cancled 3 or 4 coup against Hilter in the 1930's as Hilter approval rateing with the Germany people was 98% plus. The Germany troop support Hilter than if inmpossible to do than coup without troop support.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Zylka
|
|
quote:
They do have than name of than america who worked in our biowarfare department who is than fundie Christian and that why he isnot behind bar right now. |
Ohhh, great. I can tell this guy is gonna last long
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Zylka
|
|
Oncle B is Canadian?
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Zylka
|
|
HAHAHAHA who would have ****ing guessed. Man is Ontario ever needing another Zylka to whip things into competitive shape!!
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Zylka
|
|
Oh that's right. Montreal?
|
|
| |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:33.
Apolyton Time is 00:33. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|
05-01-2004 11:46
|