 |
|
Richard I
|
|
Oslo, Norway
Jul 2002 time: 06:20
|
|
If I ever saw a miracle, I would try to find a rational explanation to it. As it happens I haven't seen any yet.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Ramo
|
 |
Austin, Texas, USA
Oct 1999 time: 23:20
|
|
quote: I told you that before. In fact it's a technical rephrase of the question "how can something pop out of nothing"
It is impossible to prove the theory, because we can never observe 'nothing'. Vacuum is not nothing. Even complete empty vacuum is not nothing. |

The whole idea of a vacuum energy density is based on virtual particles. Without virtual particles there doesn't exist a vacuum energy density.
The Casimir effect Jakko referenced relied on the vacuum energy density to prove the existence of virtual particles.
quote: And about postive and negative energy summed up together give zero energy..........
That's a nice theory, but even in that case you need an extern source to split zero energy in X positive and X negative energy. Why would it split with no reason? |
First off, I believe you're confusing the creation of particles during inflation (which I don't really consider "something for nothing"), and the creation of virtual particles.
During the creation of a particle/anti-particle pair, energy is required. Particles can't literally come out of 0 energy without an energy surplus in the first place. However, particles close together have less gravitational potential energy than particles far apart, which was the source of energy to create the particles in our universe.
But in the case of virtual particles, the energy is "borrowed" for extraordinarily short times due to the HUP, so no other source of energy is required.
quote: It only answers the question HOW God created all this out of nothing, by splitting up positive and negative energy. |
Whatever. I don't care what you believe, as long as you don't spout ignorant BS like the universe necessitating God, or denying well-observed physical processes.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Q Cubed
|
 |
t3h y3ll0w p3ril
Apr 1999 time: 23:20
|
|
quote: Gays are sinners. Simple as that. But I'm not going to "throw the first stone" here. I know that if they are sorry for their sins Jesus will forgive them. God is very forgiving, and people like you should be grateful. |
uh... wait... didn't you just judge gays, and hence cast the first stone?
quote: So? If you scientists believe mammoths were hunted out, why not dinosaurs? And since when does believing in God make you an idiot? I think you are an idiot if you don't believe in God. |
er... see, dinosaurs and humans didn't live in the same time period... the fossil record doesn't support it.
besides, humans wouldn't have stood a fraction of a fraction of a fraction of a chance against velociraptors and the like...
quote: you're not an idiot for believing in God, you're an idiot for thinking that "because this is what I believe, that's why" stands up in an argument. |
good job, orange.
quote: But what I believe is the truth. That is why it stands up in an arguement. |
see... you've got this problem with circular logic. belief == truth. the greeks believed that there was no number that equalled the square root of two, and accepted it as truth-- yet it was proved only a few years later that there can indeed be a number that is equal to the square root of two.
your argument follows this path:
what i believe is true --> therefore, everything else is wrong --> everthing else is wrong because what i believe is true --> because what i believe is true, everything else is wrong --> everything else is wrong because what i believe is true --> (ad infinitum.)
such arguments rarely manage to convince anyone.
quote: And I am quite certain that you guys have shown that you are not Christian. |
you know what? you're right. none of us are christian.
instead, a lot of us just believe that there is one god, father almighty... that jesus was begotten of the father, born of the virgin mary, and became man, and that for our sake he was crucified under pontius pilate, suffered, died, and was buried... that on the third day he rose again, in fulfillment of the scriptures... that there is a holy spirit, who has spoken through the prophets and with the father and the son is worshipped and glorified... and that the bible, being largly symbolic, may be accurate in a lot of moral matters, is not a text we should be basing our science and our technology upon.
damn, you've caught us at our game...
quote: If you guys don't live to serve God, are you those science guys that want to freeze their bodies in tubes to live forever? That baseball player was one of "them." I think that is bogus. Everyone dies and goes to his proper place. |
DON'T YOU DARE INSULT TED WILLIAMS!
it was his bastardo son who decided he should be frozen; ted williams himself would have wanted a cremation.
======
***do you guys now understand why we will not ever be able to deal with terrorists? most fundamentalists who are terrorists are so adamant about their beliefs that they will refuse all the evidence to the contrary that what they are doing is not what is right or the truth; indeed, the original muslims were rather tolerant, and had no problem with christian pilgrimages. but now? the extremists are so focused on what they believe to be true that they are unwilling to even make the smallest concession in regards to how illogical their thought processes might be.
besides, proving god's existence is "easy": he hasn't been proven not to exist, therefore, he must exist.

|
|
|  |
 |
|
Bosh
|
 |
Taehan Mingook
Jan 1970 time: 00:20
|
|
quote: there is a God out there, regardless of how the universe was made |
A priori assumptions, gotta love 'em.
quote: Even in a singularity, gravity is there. If gravity wasn't there, then light could escape from a black hole. |
Stuff does escape black holes, thanks again to our wonderful friends (that pop uncaused out of nothing) virtual particles since one of the virtual particle pair get sucked into the hole and the other leaves the area so they don't self-annihilate like they usually do.
quote: What do you know? You tell me how the universe was created. |
A few thousand years ago people didn't know how volcanos works, that doesn't mean it was rational for them to listen to people telling them how they were caused by gods puking.
quote: If physics break down in singularities, forget about them ever making a universe. |
Try listening to people, its not physics, its all our theories about physics.
quote: You know, there IS something in the Loch Ness lake. |
For he so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son that whosoever believes in him shall believe anything.
quote: God loves us and he would never, ever do that! |
Aaaah so we would kill every single person in the entire earth except one family and command his followers to commit genocide (canaanites amelikites etc. etc.) but wouldn't stand for one plane crash, hmmmmm.
quote: If you don't live for God, then what are you doing with your life? |
This sort of philosophy really scares me. How can you possibily see nothing in life worth living for? Come on! Puppies are cute and curry tastes good!
quote: Maybe he made 2 pairs of humans and called them both Adam and Eve because he liked those names. Does it matter? |
Apologetic contortions are always fun to watch. Isn't it a hell of a lot likely that the Isrealis and the Judeans had their own versions of the greaton myth and the compilers in genesis stuck both versions in when they conflicted so as not to annoy anyone (this happens a lot in the Pentatuch (sp?)).
quote: The Bible is not wrong. In fact, you will not find any contradictions. |
hmmmmmm, BAM v2.0?
quote: quantum mechanics is a THEORY that has not been proven |
There's expirmental evidence that we know of no other explanation for than Quantum Mechanics (for example Young's parallel plate experiment where some pressure was exerted between two plates by virtual particles, ie the Casimir effect). Thus while its not proven you can't dismiss it with statements like "we no that matter can't come from nothing, therefore god did it."
quote: Didn't someone say that has to do with time? |
No.
quote: Don't try to put a silly theory or law of physics above God and what he does. |
Hard to put something above something that doesn't exist.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
King of Rasslin
|
|
Please, do not make fun of Christian Rock. I know it sucks. It has potential, but the guys that try to make Christian Rock focus too much on the lyrics and meaning than the music itself. It will get better, and not everyone that goes to the concerts looks like that. Come on.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
King of Rasslin
|
|
Actually, when you look at the shape music is in today, Christian Rock isn't so bad! As opposed to the bad guys like Britney Spears, etc. Is it ok to say you like her music but not her? Doesn't seem right.
|
|
|  |
 |
|
King of Rasslin
|
|
Her "Oops, I did it again" song is very catchy. I bet all of you hardcore athiest metalheads listen to her in private. God, metal has to be the worst garbage to happen to music, and that doesn't even include the satanic references hidden in the records.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
MOBIUS
|
 |
Prifysgol Caerdydd
Dec 1999 time: 15:20
|
|
Hey Rass, that's several pages of counter argument you've decided to ignore, in coming to the defence of 'Christian Rock' - I take it you admit defeat!
Now, if God created everything on this planet as you claim I'm assuming he created such things as:
AIDS
Parasites such as Fleas, Ticks, Tsetse Flies, Chiggers etc
Other Diseases like Ebola, Cancer, TB, Malaria, Cataracts etc
The whole Predator and Prey thing, where say a Lion viciously takes down and brutally kills a Wildebeest in the name of nature - 'Survival of the Fittest' must logically be one of God's credos. He and Hitler seem to see eye to eye in so many ways...
So, if God exists - he's not a very nice deity at all!  
After all, would you like to die from Leprosy - what a horrible way to go? Before you say those that catch the diseases etc deserve it, Father Damian in Molokai spent years tending Leprosy sufferers before catching it and dying himself...
God doesn't appear to give a Sh*t about his 'creations'!
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:20. Apolyton Time is 00:20. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|