 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
Some new young faces and one interesting omissions:
Matthew Burke, Matt Cockbain, David Croft, Ben Darwin, Owen Finegan, Elton Flatley, Adam Freier, David Giffin, Matt Giteau, George Gregan (c), Justin Harrison, Daniel Herbert, Toutai Kefu, Chris Latham, Stephen Larkham, David Lyons, Stirling Mortlock, Patricio Noriega, Jeremy Paul, Mat Rogers, Wendell Sailor, George Smith, Nick Stiles, Ben Tune, Daniel Vickerman, Chris Whitaker, Bill Young.
Phil Waugh is probably the surprise omission. Problem is, he's had only a handful of club matches back from injury and is likely to play only one more before the end of the SH season. They're leaving him behind to work on fitness.
Matt Giteau is a very young face and a back-up half back. Hasn't yet played S12, but good judges say he has terrific potential. This is long-term planning. George Gregan will be returning home at some point during the tour for the birth of a child, so Giteau will get his opporunity.
Adam Frier is the back-up hooker to Jeremy Paul. Brendan Cannen, the Waratah hooker and incumbent back-up, is grizzling about his omission. Unfortunately for Brendan, he became the incumbent via default - there was no one else around. Frier is yet another piece of long-term thinking.
The truly nice thing is that both Giteau and Frier are sons of former L***** champions. 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
How's the coffee? 
quote: Seems you are right – didn’t make the final 27. Snubbed by the ARU due to their facist “you leave you are dropped immediately” policy? Unless you are Roff and they want you back at all costs of course. |
Bondy had a couple of runs this season but he was never able to cement his place in the top team, unfortunately. He's a winger and centre and we've got several of them of real quality who outrank him. I don't know what sort of game his team over there plays, but he will repay them, regardless.
quote: A nice try at deflection but Australia’s open passport policy for sports folk can hardly be denied – so by targeting non AS names one is likely to find an import sooner rather than later. |
Keep going. 
quote: Bizarrely of course Smith is the AS surname. |
George Smith? Aboriginal heritage, actually.
quote: I would also love to see Tendulkar being from Bradford as he would be an English player then. |
You should try to organise a swap with the Indians - Tendulkar for Graham Thorpe. Poor guy, I'm really feeling sorry for him. I understand he's not the most stable temperament, but what he's going through can be ugly.
quote: My bad - Jone Tawake, young blindside flanker from your backyard in NSW. |
Now I've got him. Good young player.
quote: Glen Panaho – prop. From Qland so I can understand you not knowing the name. Both were mooted for the tour but didn’t make the 27. |
Yes, I got him. He's a local. I think there were a few unlucky young ones. But the two kids they're taking are real kids. I suppose they had to draw the line somewhere.
quote: Harrison and the untested Giffen look like the test second row with Sharpe sidelined? I hope David is fit because you cannot throw him in against us unless he is fully fit – particularly as Grewcock’s ban strangely ends just before the internationals (if his name was Johnson it might end juts before RWC!). |
Daniel Vickerman - the young South African-born bloke I mentioned - will press Harrison, though he (Vickerman) is probably going for the experience. There's talk of moving Owen Finnegan into the second row, too. Giffen is more advanced with his fitness than Phil Waugh but you're right - I hope he's up to it.
quote: And where is the cover for the back row – Smith, Kefu, Finegan is an okay unit but who steps in when they go off? |
David Croft is going. High hopes are held for him. Young bloke, skippered the A team this year which is an indication of the regard they have for him. David Lyons - whom I've spoken of before - is also there.
quote: Whilst surfing yesterday I found a page authored by a much more stereotypical Aussie than yourself who was really awfully rude (old boy) about the English - I'll see if I can drag it up as it made me laugh out loud. |
Find it. I haven't had a good cringe for a while. 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Havak
|
 |
Swing Low, Sweet Chariots.
Aug 1999 time: 05:22
|
|
The coffee is just right thanks. 
Bondy signed for Sale didn’t he? He’ll only cover the wing there – they must be looking for him as a centre. With a wing/fullback outfit of Cueto/Robinson/Hanley Bond is only going to play wing when there are injuries or those guys get rested. Still he seems used to that role. 
I don’t need to. I never accepted your rationalisation for letting Noriega pretend to be Aussie so what makes you think I’ll accept anything less than 4th generation Aussies wearing the shirt?

quote: George Smith? Aboriginal heritage, actually. |
Yup, I was actually re-enforcing your point that surnames are misleading as a guide. 
Thorpey seems on a raggard edge indeed – doesn’t know if he is coming or going. But as you say these things are not easy. It’s a crying shame for cricket as he is a quality bat when his head is in gear.
It’s a young hooker and scrummy making the trip right?
And Stiles the only actual Aussie who will face us in the first choice front row – shocking. 
I know I give Harrison a hard time in these posts but frankly I really think he has failed to meet his potential since the Lions – Sharpe looked the class of the pair throughout the tri-nations. It may be worth trying Vickerman, at the least he will be an unknown quantity.
You will of course allow me that Vickerman is not Australian and is one of the tourists I dislike so much. Hard to be an Aussie when you were born in Cape Town and have an Afrikaans surname. 
And Gregan by the way – wasn’t he actually born in Zambia?
Still Smithy is from Manly – I spent a happy day there in a bar (U-Bar?) with the newly defeated Lions who took the situation with the grace that was so clearly lacking from the other side after Brissy.
*Finbar shakes his head and says will this guy ever let it go* 
(and in case you are in doubt I’m just having fun here. I do think though that the Wallabies should have been forced to go on the p*** with the Lions rather than have that stuffy after test dinner – the only way to understand NH tradition is to dip your toe right in).
But you must treat us with more respect than bumping Finny into the second row surely? He is a good flanker – no beef there, but a back five cover is rare – Corry can do it, but Finny? Not convinced at all.
Whoops – I missed Lyons, should have caught him. For a start he seems to be your back five cover – has played lock right? Croft is new to me though, and you don’t captain the A side unless you know what you are doing (as Ben Kay also did here). This will be interesting as, all modesty aside, our back row is now awesome – picking from Hill, Back, Dallaglio, Corry and Moody. Remember you are talking about a country where the legend that is Kronfeld has to sit on his club bench because of the English talent there. 
Oh and Dallaglio is apparently fully fit and playing well. I have to admit I thought the last injury might end him as a top flight player but I’m sure he will figure in the autumn now.
Actually Havak was given a rare treat last weekend to see the opposition faces as Lewis Moody was taken off on 60 minutes and the already reeling Newcastle side saw a totally hyper Josh come on and throw himself everywhere for the rest of the game.
We are badly spoilt in some ways at Welford Road – but at least we know it. 
I only got as far as the word “ripper” in Pool A in the diatribes and my brain switched off. Particularly as I think Ireland may surprise him. 
And I just totally dismissed the racist nonsense about the Japies and England. He and anyone else simply writing off England are very misguided indeed. 
|
|
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
The coffee is just right thanks. |
Goodoh. Instant? Or the real thing? I only drink the real thing out of a real machine. So I bought one. Other than that, it's tea.
quote: Bondy signed for Sale didn’t he? |
Yep.
quote: With a wing/fullback outfit of Cueto/Robinson/Hanley Bond is only going to play wing when there are injuries or those guys get rested. |
Then he'll play centre. He's certainly strong enough and his skills are good enough.
quote: so what makes you think I’ll accept anything less than 4th generation Aussies wearing the shirt? |
Of course you won't. But you keep putting 'em up, I'll keep knocking 'em down. BTW, how unItalian is Lawrence "Snorter" Dallaglio? 
quote: It’s a young hooker and scrummy making the trip right? |
Yeah, the latter can play halfback and 5/8 apparently. Frankly, I know next to nothing about him. He's only 20, he's played rep 7s and U21s but hasn't yet played S12. Apparently Glen Ella tipped off Eddie Jones about him a while ago.
quote: I know I give Harrison a hard time in these posts but frankly I really think he has failed to meet his potential since the Lions – Sharpe looked the class of the pair throughout the tri-nations. It may be worth trying Vickerman, at the least he will be an unknown quantity. |
I wouldn't disagree about Harrison. He can't live off robbing Jonno forever. Sharpe made him look a bit average by comparison and he (Sharpe) is quite a deal younger too.
quote: You will of course allow me that Vickerman is not Australian and is one of the tourists I dislike so much. Hard to be an Aussie when you were born in Cape Town and have an Afrikaans surname. |
As I've said before - if your parents up and off to another country, what are you going to do? Doesn't worry me in the slightest.
quote: And Gregan by the way – wasn’t he actually born in Zambia? |
Don't your read my posts? Australian-Zambian parents, came here when he was one!
quote: (and in case you are in doubt I’m just having fun here. I do think though that the Wallabies should have been forced to go on the p*** with the Lions rather than have that stuffy after test dinner – the only way to understand NH tradition is to dip your toe right in). |
Who knows why things happen? Certainly the Wallabies and the ABs socialise. Gregan and Justin Marshall and Mehrtens are all good mates, they do BBQs at each other's places.
quote: But you must treat us with more respect than bumping Finny into the second row surely? He is a good flanker – no beef there, but a back five cover is rare – Corry can do it, but Finny? Not convinced at all. |
I'm not sure what the Finnegan thing is all about. There was talk of it happening earlier this season but it didn't. I suspect it might be a concern about him losing his pace as he's getting on. He's made it clear this is his last season. Actually, I think they will probably consider him as a back-up second rower, a cover in case Giffen has problems, etc. I gather they want to start David Lyons (in Finnegan's spot) so Finnegan might even finish up coming off the bench for impact. He's highly valued within the team.
quote: Whoops – I missed Lyons, should have caught him. For a start he seems to be your back five cover – has played lock right? |
He's always played flanker or #8. Finnegan's successor, basically. He's big enough to play lock if need be.
quote: Croft is new to me though, and you don’t captain the A side unless you know what you are doing (as Ben Kay also did here). |
Went from S12 to the A team to captaining the A team to the Wallaby bench against the French in about a month. Talked about as a future Wallaby skipper.
quote: Oh and Dallaglio is apparently fully fit |
Nostrils clear? 
quote: I only got as far as the word “ripper” in Pool A in the diatribes and my brain switched off. Particularly as I think Ireland may surprise him. |
I didn't think he was unkind about the Irish. It's worth going back and having a look at his assessments. He predicts an AB-Boks final, won by the ABs.
Last edited by finbar on 26-09-2002 at 17:29
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
Instant sadly. The occasional Latte from a packet too (don’t ask). |
Post here as soon as you get into work. I'll whip up a bona fide latte and email it to you! 
quote: As I think you know it’s residency that bugs me – and Vickerman is a case in point not being Australian in truth in any other way at all. At least Catt got in through parentage (as indeed will Horak if he can ever string a run together – awesome at times but scary at others – plays for London Irish) |
I know we're going around in circles on this one but there's only one logical conclusion to your argument in a Vickerman case. If a chap's family ups and offs with him and his siblings to another country - and become citizens - when he's a dependent child, the chap can't/shouldn't represent that country? Sorry.
quote: Based on what you have said before if Glen Ella has tipped someone that is definitely one to watch. Hope he gets a proper run in a big game (in other words not Italy). |
He won't, failing disasters. There are experienced back-ups in front of him - Whitaker at halfback, Flatley at 5/8 - and I expect he's along purely for the experience of being exposed to the atmosphere. He wouldn't even have met most of the squad.
From what I can gather, there's going to be a lot of experimentation against Argentina. I don't know whether Eddie's winding up Jeremy Paul, but he's saying he has plans to start the young hooker - Freier - against the Pumas. Mortlock is moving from the wing to outside centre (where he really belongs), Matt Rogers and Wendell Sailor will start - Rogers for Latham at fullback, I suspect - and David Lyons will also start. I'm not sure where they fit Matt Burke into that equation.
quote: He’s been largely anonymous since then. It’s a shame as he seems a nice lad (off the field!). I remarked how well he interviewed last touring season – he can take the mickey out of himself which is good – imagine Healey or Farr-Jones doing the same? |
He's a terrific personality. Very dry. Great p*ss-taker, especially about himself. His background was Australian Rules and hadn't played rugby till he got to uni. He tells the story of arriving at Orientation Week at uni, checking out the sporting clubs on the noticeboard, discovering that the rugby club was offering a keg of beer to attract players - thus his sporting future was decided. 
I have to say, for what it's worth, the current Wallaby squad posseses a highly developed wit, far superior to our other sporting outfits. I think it could have something to do with the fact that they're a very tight, united outfit without the factions and rifts that have split earlier Wallaby squads.
quote: One parent eh? Dubious qualification then. Does he have an English grandparent? I’m sure the IRB will overlook that small matter of his Aussie caps if he wants to change. |
There's probably cannibalism somewhere back in George's ancestry, so tell your halfback to count his extremities before he leaves the field next time.
quote: From what I hear most players try to avoid Umaga when he goes out? Gets a bit carried away at times? |
I'd certainly avoid him out - drunk or sober! 
quote: I’d rather see England-ABs as I might get a ticket then as all the Aussies try to flog them. |
With an England-ABs final, no prizes for guessing who the Australian crowd will be cheering for! 
|
|
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
I haven't even checked if England and the ABs are in the correct parts of the draw to be able to meet. We would meet in the quarters if that diatribe writer is correct. But I think we will win our pool which might give us the ABs if we make the final. |
From what I can fathom, the diatribe writer is correct - if the ABs win their Pool and England come second in theirs, you meet the ABs in the first quarter-final.
Let's play "what if". If England wins their Pool, they play in the fourth quarter-final against the pool D runner-up. Pool D, the ABs apart, couldn't be more appropriately named - Wales, Canada, Europe 2, Repecharge 2. You'd have to assume England would win.
Thus England would meet meet the winner of the third quarter-final in the second semi-final. The third quarter-final should have involved Ireland (2nd to Australia in their Pool) and France (who should have won the Pool consisting of France, Scotland, Fiji, Japan, and Repechage 1 [probably another of the Pacific Island nations]). So it's more than likely England -v- France in the second semi-final.
This "what if England win their Pool" scenario is interesting. If they do, it will match the Boks against the ABs in the first quarter-final.
The second quarter-final, assuming Australia wins their Pool against Argentina, Europe 1, Europe 4 and Africa 1, will pit the Wallabies against whomever comes second to France in Pool B out of Scotland, Fiji, Japan and probably one of the other Pacific Island nations. It's not beyond reason that someone like Fiji could cause an upset in that Pool. Anyway, Australia should win.
Thus the first semi-final would be Australia -v- either the ABs or the Boks.
Followed by the second semi-final of a likely England -v- France.
Thus winning that Pool C is vitally important for both England and the Boks. Either way, it virtually guarantees a semi-final spot. If the Boks win the Pool, their quarter-final would be against either Wales or Europe 2 (or Canada). If they come second in the Pool, they run into the ABs.
Very, very interesting.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
If only you could. |
Mmmm. On second thoughts, it would probably spill via email. How about international courier? It should be waiting for you on your desk on Monday morning.
quote: It’s a fundamental point of view with me and I don’t expect to ever convert you. It goes beyond rugby with me. I have little time for people who change nationality unless they come from a country where they face persecution simply for their beliefs or ethnic background. People who change nationality on what seem to be whims, like all the silly Brits who become ‘Americans’ (mainly for tax avoidance – ssshh!), baffle the hell out of me. What rationale is there for being Aussie rather than Bok? Both countries have massive racism problems and poor economies after all? |
Oh well. I suppose there are some who do it on a whim but I think most would have some valid reason. We should probably let this one go through to the keeper.
quote: Rogers at fullback would be an interesting choice I think – he has strength and pace and skills and could make the spot his own. |
He's a very skilled player. Some are saying that Latham was lucky to make the trip. There's a bit of a whispering campaign against him - his judgement is suspect, he's too often out of position. I suspect the whisperers were cheering him on earlier in the season.
quote: Burke must be spitting chips. |
He could be a bit stiff. He was a good fullback, he's done nothing wrong at centre. OTOH, I'd rather have him kicking for goal for my life than Stirling Mortlock.
quote: How much of what Eddie is hinting is just mind games though? A little wasted on the Pumas perhaps as whatever team you field they will give you one hell of a physical test up front but I would expect your superior back division to tell (significantly) in the end. Remember the England B side beat them down there in June. |
I think they're certainly going to use the Pumas to try out a few things. Rogers is too talented to keep coming off the bench, as is Lyons, and Mortlock's spot is in the centres. Organising all that is going to mean some serious rearrangement.
quote: I think, from what little I have seen, I would love you to play Sailor at Twickenham. Can’t kick to save his life which should put your defence under some pressure. |
Frankly, I wish he'd go back to L*****. He's a superb athlete, and that's it.
quote: *cough* Do you think the refined wit of the squad might just have something to do with the fact they are successful too? |
No, I'm talking about the personalities involved.
quote: Very kind of the generous Aussie sporting public to get behind the Poms. 
After all, you yourself said the Aussie public backs the underdogs. You aren’t going to tell me that was wrong now are you? |
I'm glad you laughed out loud. We do draw the line somewhere! 
quote: By the way you have me in a very difficult position you know. The game is televised tomorrow and I will be forced to support Bath. You simply do not know what you have forced me into there. It's almost unthinkable. |

Actually, I've got a hard night of FoxSports ahead of me tonight flicking between Australia -v- Sri Lanka in that meaningless 1-day comp, and the Ryder Cup, where I'm obviously barracking for GB&E, providing Monty loses every match and breaks his fat, miserable, whingeing leg along the way. 
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:22. Apolyton Time is 00:22. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|