 |
|
Caligastia
|
|
quote: Originally posted by finbar
It seems to be predicated on the fact that the Wallabies and Boks will be there anyway as part of their NH tour. Presumably the ABs aren't touring |
Yeah, but there is talk of the competition becoming a permanent annual event if it is successful. I agree though, there does need to be more regular competition between the two hemispheres. Its a pity that north v south idea never got off the ground.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Caligastia
Yeah, but there is talk of the competition becoming a permanent annual event if it is successful. |
I just noticed that. There's absolutely nil reference to the ABs, not even that they turned down the idea. Maybe they just think 4 would be too many. I must look into it.
Edit. There's no mention of it on the NZRFU site. But there's an interesting observation on Planet Rugby:
quote: The new competition could spell the end of the SANZAR Tri-Nations, the current deal for that competition expiring in 2005, as three of the top four nations in world rugby move closer to a synchronised global rugby season. |
How long ago was it that the Boks were talking about joining the 6 Nations? Very interesting piece of extrapolation.
quote: Its a pity that north v south idea never got off the ground. |
The IRB just re-mooted it (so to speak) as a fundraiser this November and the England and Australian Player Unions knocked it back on the grounds of player fatigue. Yet an alternative that has the same problem is being seriously proposed. I'm not sure that the IRB will warm to the new proposal even if the players and clubs buy it.
Last edited by finbar on 01-10-2002 at 19:15
|
|
|  |
 |
|
Caligastia
|
|
Interesting quote from planet rugby there. If this new competition was to replace the SANZAR Tri-nations competition I think they would have to at least include the All Blacks. The ideal would be to include France too. I they did that they would have to create another competition for those 6-nations countries left in the cold.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
Much as it shames me to admit it Finbar I am the first rugby nut in my family. Before that the paternal line was football all the way. I’m considered something of a black sheep. |
Mmmmm. But you know what they say about throwbacks in families. If I ever hear of you hurling yourself to the ground in some penalty box somewhere clutching at some part of your anatomy and squealing for a penalty - you're in big trouble! 
quote: Whatever your background it’s really your history too – the good and the bad of it – if only for the language you are using to post. |
You're most generous. I would still rather own it than get my kicks vicariously.
quote: You know thinking about it Finbar you have rather de-railed Toulouse with your support. I only hope you can work the same charm on ‘Glaws’. |
I'm thinking of taking up barracking for George W. Bush - the man whose only ever dream, I kid you not, was to run one of the national baseball leagues - for obvious reasons.
quote: Sadly I doubt it – strong squad, good coach, solid captain. Our best bet is still their going bankrupt. |
I'm starting up a Save The Gloucester RFC Fund. I know I can count on you for at least a couple of bits of lint from the bottom of one of your pockets. 
quote: I see the RFU are now denying that the ABs are being excluded, and the concept seems to be a wider one of also scheduling lengthier tours between France/England and the SANZAR nations? |
Methinks there's some placating going on, as I suggested in my last post. And, as it happens, the NZRFU is saying they want fewer matches of higher quality. That, I suspect, is pretty heavy-handed code for ditching the S12.
quote: I’m not sure I like the idea of either tri-nations of six nations going though – way too much history there. |
Yes, but it seems to me that if the game is going to be truly international - by which I mean parallel seasons (as much as that's possible) - then the hemisphere-based comps would have to go in order to clear the way. I suppose it depends, ultimately, on what value is placed on the game being truly international. Or, in fact, whether it ever can be.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Havak
|
 |
Swing Low, Sweet Chariots.
Aug 1999 time: 05:22
|
|
quote: A North vs South competition without France or New Zealand would be ridiculous |

Well said!
quote: Though Havak and I can have a similar opinion I doubt our respective Unions can, so this kind of competition is not ready to be created |
Money will be the stumbling block. The RFU has many faults, but it knows how to rake in the cash. This proposal is largely about sharing the wealth. For example this November the RFU will keep well over 90% of the revenue from the three fixtures which is very lucrative. Were England to tour NZ the NZRFU would do the same (though in purely cash terms that won’t gain them the same level of income I suspect).
We do need to be careful that the developing nations – like Wales – are not totally excluded?
quote: It's also interesting to read the English Union doing a lot of oil-on- potentially-troubled-waters pouring at Planet Rugby. |
Well it needed doing I think, and probably better left to the English. I mean can you imaging O’Neil trying diplomacy? At the same time it is partly self created as a problem – they persistently avoid England during their vacations to the NH – for example they were up here last year but avoided us to play Celts if I recall – what is the point of that, and why should they be surprised if we hold a party and don’t invite them after all the invites they have snubbed? I’ll give this to Australia – they are always willing to play us be it here or down under. 
I have to say Finbar if you ever catch me playing soccer I will accept whatever censure the committee here passes on me. I do however have to reserve the right that I may still clutch parts of my anatomy and scream for a penalty (“penalty sir?”) just in case I get on a rugger pitch again. 
quote: I would still rather own it than get my kicks vicariously. |
Well it’s rich but it isn’t unqualifiedly great (please excuse my suspect grammar). I enjoy my nations history but I am not as close minded about it as some nationalists. There are some nasty dark chapters and as is ever the case those chapters tend to be the most interesting.
quote: I'm starting up a Save The Gloucester RFC Fund |
A noble cause indeed. I’ll start collecting lint now. 
quote: That, I suspect, is pretty heavy-handed code for ditching the S12. |
Do you really think so? I wouldn’t be totally surprised to be honest as it is easy to see what S12 does for the Wallabies but it is less clear what it does for the ABs – NZ has high class domestic competition to fall back on as oft mentioned here.
quote: what value is placed on the game being truly international |
I think we need to set more modest targets. A global season is very ambitious and would only ever happen if you moved to match our pattern I suspect. Rugby in summer is OZ – talk about hard ground!!
Seriously I can’t ever see the English adjusting their season away from winter so it’s a non-starter. And sure fewer higher quality games make a great sound bite but the reality is it needs a ground up re-working of the game – it’s unlikely to say the least?
And it’s hard to convey, though I know I have tried before, but there’s a hard core here who care more about smashing the Welsh regularly than about close tough matches with SANZAR opponents. That attitude would need to be overcome as well. A tricky proposal. 
quote: They called me the Human Calculator. |
Are you sure you heard them correctly? 
My tour party has already encountered problems with the Euro -, on a scouting mission to Brussels last week the locals refused to take Irish Euros from them. So what is the point of a single currency again?
This is where Europe went wrong you see – there is a ready made single currency, it’s called ‘Sterling’. 
|
|
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
We do need to be careful that the developing nations – like Wales – are not totally excluded? |
I appreciate the irony.
quote: Well it needed doing I think, and probably better left to the English. I mean can you imaging O’Neil trying diplomacy? |
Well, he did set aside 3,000 tickets at the WRC final specifically for AB fans. I haven't heard them say thank you.
quote: At the same time it is partly self created as a problem – they persistently avoid England during their vacations to the NH – for example they were up here last year but avoided us to play Celts if I recall – what is the point of that, and why should they be surprised if we hold a party and don’t invite them after all the invites they have snubbed? |
Well, they prefer the Celts because, on the NZRFU website, they say they want fewer matches of higher quality. I imagine there's a kind of logic in there somewhere.
quote: I’ll give this to Australia – they are always willing to play us be it here or down under. |
And why not? A joust against the Old Country in any sport is good stuff.
quote: I do however have to reserve the right that I may still clutch parts of my anatomy and scream for a penalty (“penalty sir?”) just in case I get on a rugger pitch again. |

I imagine you've lost a bit of your nip over the first five yards?
quote: Well it’s rich but it isn’t unqualifiedly great (please excuse my suspect grammar). I enjoy my nations history but I am not as close minded about it as some nationalists. There are some nasty dark chapters and as is ever the case those chapters tend to be the most interesting. |
That's the point, I think - good, bad, ugly, it's rich and interesting, sometimes to be condemned, often to be celebrated, and can still inform life today. But if you ain't got it, none of the preceding can apply.
quote: Do you really think so? I wouldn’t be totally surprised to be honest as it is easy to see what S12 does for the Wallabies but it is less clear what it does for the ABs – NZ has high class domestic competition to fall back on as oft mentioned here. |
The Kiwis are well known to want to be rid of the S12. As you say, they don't need it. OTOH, we do.
quote: I think we need to set more modest targets. A global season is very ambitious and would only ever happen if you moved to match our pattern I suspect. Rugby in summer is OZ – talk about hard ground!! |
Summer wouldn't work, but spring or autumn would.
quote: Seriously I can’t ever see the English adjusting their season away from winter so it’s a non-starter. And sure fewer higher quality games make a great sound bite but the reality is it needs a ground up re-working of the game – it’s unlikely to say the least? |
The latter point's the key, I think. The sort of cooperation between the various Unions required to pull off a global season is immensely unlikely.
quote: And it’s hard to convey, though I know I have tried before, but there’s a hard core here who care more about smashing the Welsh regularly than about close tough matches with SANZAR opponents. That attitude would need to be overcome as well. A tricky proposal. |
I can understand the desire to smash the Welsh. It parallels the Australia-New Zealand situation, though the quality of the oppo is marginally different in our case.
quote: So what is the point of a single currency again? |
Don't get me started on it! Creeping homogenisation driven by the money men.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
Caligastia
|
|
I would be sorry to see the super 12 go, but if it enabled the creation of a more international annual tournament it would be worth it. The hemispheres really are too polarized, I mean we have two annual competitions between the same three nations down here.
If there is to be widespread change in the current structure of rugby competitions (i.e. scrapping of the super12, six and tri nations), this is what I would like to see emerge.
- A new 6 nations with NZ, SA, Oz, England, France and Argentina. In this competition we would have the top five teams in the world, with a developing rugby nation thrown in there. Argentina would benefit immensely from playing against the "big five" on a regular basis, and the benefits would also no doubt be passed on to Chile.
- A new 6 nations type of european competition with Ireland, Wales, Scotland, Italy, Georgia and Romania. As Ireland, Wales, and Scotland are a significant step down from England and France, but a significant step up from Italy, Georgia and Romania, the latter three countries would greatly benefit from regular play against the former. Perhaps even Russia could be brought in at some stage. Ireland, Wales and Scotland could still have the occasional test series against France and England.
This is all open to discussion of course. What do you guys think?
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|
finbar
|
 |
Castiglion Fiorentino, Italy
Jan 1970 time: 06:22
|
|
quote: Originally posted by Havak
There is a twisted logic yes – “fewer matches of higher quality” could be read as “more matches of lower quality”. This of course is what you implied. |

quote: I agree in a qualified way. I like it to be sports where the clash is at least competitive. So I will not be glued to the ashes it is safe to say. |
All the better, obviously, if it's competitive. It will be interesting to see what effect, if any, Rodney Marsh and his academy have on your cricket standards. He seems to have an opinion of the two new young quicks who are coming here. I only saw them briefly in the recent series over there and they looked handy for their age. At least our pitches here will help them if they've got strong backs and the commitment.
quote: Rowing, of all things, seems to be an area where we can compete. Shame it’s so boring then really. |
Yes, it must be disspiriting to lead the world in so many crashingly boring sports like rowing and that bizarre Winter Olympics event where they slide something down an ice lane and chase it with brooms. 
quote: Excellent point. I particularly like your remark on the way it can inform life today, too few people understand that very thing. |
Not to mention those who are too arrogant or stupid (or both) to learn from past mistakes.
quote: What months would that be? Thinking about it our season runs Autumn-Spring already (Aug-May) |
The weather would be suitable here from March onwards, through until late September, perhaps into October.
quote: There are extended parallels though. They used to be better than us, then we drew level, then we left them in our dust. All you need to do is do the latter to the ABs and the cases will match entirely. |
It's on the cards. 
quote: Can you truly imagine my countrymen ever being fully homogenised into Europeans? |
Absolutely not. Nor, I hope, will it happen elsewhere in Europe. In fact, given the local pride, it probably won't. But the blight on our civilisation that is the money men, to whom culture and identity is no priority at all, will do their damndest.
|
|
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
|  |
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:22. Apolyton Time is 00:22. |
top of page
|
| archivepost |
|
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
|
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
|
|
|
|
|
|